6. Were there prophecies in advance about every prophet as to when he would come, and also a specification of the geographical region in which he would appear? For example, the Gospel tells us that at the birth of Jesus, some people reached Bethlehem guided by a star. Is there any such prophecy about Hazrat Mirza Sahib as well that specifies the region of his advent? Also, please mention some of the signs of his truthfulness.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 February 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Were there prophecies in advance about every prophet as to when he would come, and also a specification of the geographical region in which he would appear? For example, the Gospel tells us that at the birth of Jesus, some people reached Bethlehem guided by a star. Is there any such prophecy about Hazrat Mirza Sahib as well that specifies the region of his advent? Also, please mention some of the signs of his truthfulness.
A prophecy like the narration from the Bible that he has presented does not exist regarding the Promised Messiah (as); nor did that prophecy ever exist regarding the Messiah. These fictitious stories were made up later by the Christians; they have no proof, they present something that contradicts the history of the prophets, and something that is rationally impossible. No sensible person can accept that prophecy as being from God. For they relate that those star-worshippers followed a star, walking behind it. When the moon rises, however far you walk, the moon goes along with you, and wherever you stop, the moon stops. Have you ever seen the moon point to a particular house? And that star stood over the house in which the Messiah had been born; and they went and spoke, and it turned out: yes, the child is here, this is he. This testimony was not seen by those Jews who were alarmed even by the idea of his messengership – that such a child, who has no father, why should they talk about his messengership? And how does a star stop over a particular house? This is like the joke people have made about the hospitality of the Peshawaris: the Pathans are very hospitable, but they say the Peshawaris, mixed with Pathans, do not know the manners of hospitality. They say: when you go to meet them, they will say they are very pleased, they will slaughter a goat for you and serve you. Then you ask them where to come, give me the address of the house – they say: see that kite flying there? Our house is beneath it. A house beneath a flying kite might perhaps still be found, one might estimate it; but how will one find a house beneath a star? He has asked about something that does not exist and cannot exist. Therefore I concede, and I am happy to concede, that there was no such prophecy regarding the Promised Messiah (as).
As far as prophecies are concerned, that is a separate subject; as far as specifying the place is concerned, that is a separate subject. Now I will tell you about both of these. In the Holy Qur’an the second advent (Bi‘that Thaniya) of the Holy Prophet (saw) is mentioned, and in very clear words. How that second advent will take place, the Hadith of Bukhari – an authentic Hadith, about whose soundness none of the scholars has had any doubt – bears witness. In that same Hadith the region is also specified, but not in the sense that he will be beneath wherever a star stands; rather a general specification has been given. So the prophecy is in the Holy Qur’an, the Hadith explained that prophecy and specified the region. These are the three claims I have made.
Which verse of the Holy Qur’an is it? In Surah Al-Jumu‘ah Allah says: “He it is Who has raised among the unlettered people a Messenger from among themselves, who recites to them His Signs, purifies them and teaches them the Book and wisdom, although they had been before in manifest error; and among others from among them who have not yet joined them …” He is God, the God of Muhammad Mustafa (saw), Who raised this Messenger among the unlettered – an utterly ignorant, illiterate people; among them He raised this Messenger. But ‘from among themselves’: he himself was also unlettered, he was one of them. But what a sudden revolution took place! He recites to them the Signs of Allah; he began reciting. And he was such a holy soul, such a pure spirit, that with his recitation people’s souls began to become pure – ‘purifies them’: he began to purify them. Whoever came near him, even if he was dust, turned into gold. This astonishing transforming power of purification that was in Muhammad (saw) is being pointed to: that after reciting the verses, before giving their knowledge, before explaining their wisdoms, he began purifying people through his holy spiritual power. “And teaches them the Book and wisdom”: and after that he began teaching them the Book and explaining the wisdom of the Book. That is, the verses that were revealed he presented, and purified; when people became pure they became capable of understanding the subjects and meanings of the Holy Qur’an. For the Holy Qur’an says: “None shall touch it except those who are purified” – no one can even touch the subjects of this Book except those who are pure or have been purified. So see how this verse, in support of that verse in the Holy Qur’an, with what glory lifts the veils from this subject: Muhammad Mustafa (saw) recited and made people pure; seeing him, his company removed every rust from people’s beings. Then they became fit for the teaching of the Book, then they became worthy of having the wisdoms explained and of understanding those wisdoms. All these things He has stated.
Then Allah says: “… raised among the unlettered a Messenger from among themselves, who recites to them His Signs, purifies them and teaches them the Book and wisdom, although they had been before in manifest error” – before this they were in manifest error. What does the next verse say? “And among others from among them” – and among others besides them too He will raise him. No other prophet is being talked about; He will raise Muhammad (saw) among other people besides them, who are not the contemporaries resembling you, but some other people coming later – “who have not yet joined them”, who had no connection with them; among them too He will send Hazrat Muhammad (saw). “And He is the Mighty, the Wise” – and He is dominant and exalted and full of wisdom. Why will this happen? He said: “That is Allah’s grace”, “He bestows it on whom He pleases” – on whom He pleases He will bestow this grace. No one can stay His hand; no one can say: give it to the Arabs, give it to the non-Arabs. He is the Master, He is free to choose. Just as the first time He decided that the Messenger should be from the unlettered, the next time too He will decide where he should descend again. “And among others from among them who have not yet joined them; and He is the Mighty, the Wise. That is Allah’s grace; He bestows it on whom He pleases” – Allah’s grace, He gives it to whom He pleases – “and He is the Mighty, the Wise.”
Now listen: when these verses were revealed, the Companions were present; one was a non-Arab, but all were Arabs. In their presence this verse was revealed. Bukhari tells us that this is the event of its revelation and this is the occasion of its revelation: thus it was revealed, and upon its revelation the Companions asked a question in astonishment. The questioner asked: O Messenger of Allah, who will be those people of whom this verse speaks? They understood that Muhammad (saw) would descend again, because no other prophet was being talked about. That is why no one asked: O Messenger of Allah, will you descend again? Because it was understood; they understood that this verse was saying that among the later ones this same Prophet who had been raised would be raised again. So they did not consider that question necessary. He asked: who will those people be, which later ones are being talked about? When the question was repeated three times, the third time the Holy Prophet (saw) placed his hand on the shoulder of Salman Farsi, who was sitting there, and what answer did he give? “Even if faith were at the Pleiades (Thurayya), a man from among these would surely attain it”; and in another narration: “men from among these” – not one man is being spoken of; several pure men will do this work. So this is the meaning of this verse. Now can anyone in the world explain the clear verses of the Holy Qur’an better than the Holy Prophet (saw)? And an explanation that Bukhari has preserved, an explanation to which neither Sunni nor Shia has objected. And this is the explanation.
Think about this too: he says, “Even if faith were at the Pleiades” – i.e. this event belongs to that age, will happen in that age when faith will practically have departed from the world. Even if it had reached the Pleiades, “a man from among these would attain it” – a person who will be from among these people will bring it back from the Pleiades. He did not put his hand on Arab shoulders; he put his hand on the shoulder of a non-Arab. And he indicated the place and fixed the time. Because it was impossible that here the Holy Prophet (saw) would pass away and there faith would rise to the Pleiades and nothing would remain. The Holy Prophet (saw) says that the first three generations will be generations of light, my light will remain alive and established; darkness will come afterwards, and then for a thousand years there will be darkness. So this is an event occurring after thirteen hundred years, about which it can be said that faith has risen to the Pleiades. It does not mean that Muslims will deny Islam; it does not mean they will give up the prayers. It does not mean that because another Hadith explains this subject clearly. The Holy Prophet (saw) says: “A time will come upon the people when nothing will remain of Islam except its name, and nothing of the Holy Qur’an except its script; their mosques will be thronged, but empty of guidance; their scholars will be the worst under the canopy of heaven.” The age in which the rising of faith is spoken of – they say, tell us the signs too. The signs are these, which Muhammad (saw) himself stated. He said: among the later ones in whom my second advent is mentioned, I will not come; a servant of mine will come, and his coming will be as if my coming, because he will be obedient to me; he will not bring anything new. From whom will he be? Not from the Arabs; he will be from the non-Arabs (Ahl-e-Ajam), because there was only one non-Arab, on whose shoulder the hand was placed: Salman Farsi. That he will be of his people, or that he will be a non-Arab – you can make both translations.
And then he said something remarkable: the signs of the age in which faith will have gone to the Pleiades are these: “A time will come upon the people” – a time will come upon these people when Islam will remain in name only: “except its name” – it will remain in name; Islam will not remain. “And nothing of the Holy Qur’an except its script” – the Holy Qur’an will not be lifted, there will be many copies of it, very beautiful calligraphies; its outward form will be there, but the Holy Qur’an will not be. What is the state of the mosques? He said: the mosques will not be deserted – “thronged” – the mosques will be populated, “but empty of guidance”. Their mosques will outwardly be populated, but completely devoid of guidance. There you will hear political talk, stories of their own liking will be told, you will hear talk of quarrelling with one another. The remembrance of God, for which the mosques were dedicated, with love and sincerity – that remembrance will not take place there; other things will be talked about there. That is why he said: “Their mosques will be thronged” – it is wrong that the mosques will be empty; the mosques will remain full, “but empty of guidance” – yet the state will be that they are empty of guidance. So this is the subject that faith will rise to the Pleiades, as the Holy Prophet (saw) himself has explained.
Someone might think: fine, at least the scholars will remain; we will go to the scholars and get guidance again. He said: forget that too. “Their scholars will be the worst under the canopy of heaven” – their scholars will be the worst creatures beneath the firmament, the most wicked creatures. “From them the disorders will emerge, from them the disorders will emerge, and into them they will return” – all disorders will spring from them, from the scholars of your Ummah, whom you think to be people who give you support in religion, who are responsible for keeping your religion established. ‘Min hum’ and ‘min ‘indihim’ – the meaning of both is the same, both are correct, but the wording is: “Min ‘indihim takhruju al-fitan” – disorders will spring from them, “wa fihim ta‘ud” – and keep returning into them. Again and again movements of disorder will issue from them, and in the end they will absorb them back into themselves, their own statements. Today they will say: you are out of the pale of Islam, you irreligious ones, disbelievers, your blood is lawful; the next day they will be photographed hand in hand: see, the Ummah has become one. One time they will say Shias cannot be Muslims, they are the worst of creatures; the next day pictures will be printed in the ‘Jang’ newspaper of Shias and Sunnis hand in hand, wearing long robes, saying: forget yesterday, we take back that statement. One day they will say a woman’s leadership cannot be accepted, it is un-Islamic, and stir up disorder; the next day, as heads of foreign committees under that same woman, they will be talking of representing her in the world. This is the explanation.
Now things have been laid open; what more do you want opened? And as for the other arguments for the truthfulness of the Promised Messiah (as), I have already placed the basic principles before you. This answer has already come in the first answer, so let us leave it here; only ten minutes remain. In my view the answer in principle has been given. For details we have video cassettes, audio cassettes and books. Give him a copy of ‘Dawat-ul-Amir’; if he reads it, God willing, he will find in it in abundance further supporting signs of the truthfulness of the Promised Messiah (as). Alright.