8. Huzoor, my question is long and needs explanation; if time is short I will not ask it. … Namely: the Holy Prophet (saw) was sent and spread Islam in a very beautiful manner, and his claim remained hidden in Mecca. That claim received strength when… [Huzoor: Hidden? Do you mean he made the claim secretly?] …subdued; the claim was not open at that time. [Huzoor: That is not correct, forgive me. The Holy Qur’an and the history of Islam refute this. His claim was proclaimed loudly; it reached every person in Mecca, there was not a single one for whom it was in any sense unclear. When the people of Mecca shut their doors on him after hearing the claim, he went out to the surrounding settlements and began conveying the same claim to others. That is correct. Now the next part of the question.] In any case, it received zeal, fervour and strength when an Islamic state… the sword was raised. [Huzoor: You may say that too…] I do not say it, people say it: when the foundation of an Islamic state was laid in Medina and a centre was formed…

Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 February 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Huzoor, my question is long and needs explanation; if time is short I will not ask it. … Namely: the Holy Prophet (saw) was sent and spread Islam in a very beautiful manner, and his claim remained hidden in Mecca. That claim received strength when… [Huzoor: Hidden? Do you mean he made the claim secretly?] …subdued; the claim was not open at that time. [Huzoor: That is not correct, forgive me. The Holy Qur’an and the history of Islam refute this. His claim was proclaimed loudly; it reached every person in Mecca, there was not a single one for whom it was in any sense unclear. When the people of Mecca shut their doors on him after hearing the claim, he went out to the surrounding settlements and began conveying the same claim to others. That is correct. Now the next part of the question.] In any case, it received zeal, fervour and strength when an Islamic state… the sword was raised. [Huzoor: You may say that too…] I do not say it, people say it: when the foundation of an Islamic state was laid in Medina and a centre was formed…

I understand your question. It is long, but well known; if I misunderstand it and answer, stop me. Please sit down. This question mostly arises from studying the school of Maududi, because Maududi wrote that the Holy Prophet (saw) exhausted all means of admonition; all measures of persuading with wisdom and love failed, admonition proved useless; only when he set out with the sword in hand did that sword cut away the rust of centuries – and in his view that is the victory of Islam. If hearts can be conquered by the sword, then Islam has no truth at all. A religion that cannot pierce hearts with arguments and claims – even if it spread under threat of beheading, it would have no truth whatsoever. And the history of Islam refutes this. The state that is claimed to have been established was never established. Islam spread first. The Holy Prophet (saw) went to Medina, and there were continuous conspiracies against him. A covenant was made with the people of Medina, called Mithaq-e-Madina (the Charter of Medina). According to this charter he accepted certain principles of give and take in order to live there. And throughout this period conspiracies continued against him, against his mothers (of the believers), against his pure wives, against the Muslims; there were even attempts to cause harm. To call this dominance is so unjustified, for in that Medina he did not yet have even numerical superiority over the Jews and other Christians; the tribes remained divided there as before. Upon that Medina all the Arab tribes poured in at the Battle of the Confederates (Ahzab). To say he had been granted victory and established a state is completely wrong. The Battle of Badr could not have happened if a state had been granted to him upon arriving in Medina; where then did the Battle of Badr come from? In it all the Muslims, young and old, elderly and weak combined, were three hundred and thirteen, and against them, having come two hundred and fifty miles from Mecca, mounted young men on she-camels and mares numbered a thousand. What sort of state was this? Three hundred and thirteen, despite their weakness, defeated a thousand. This was a divine state, this was heavenly help, otherwise it was impossible. That was the event, not the power of the sword. Then look at the next battle, Uhud: facing the Holy Prophet (saw) with seven hundred was an army of three thousand, a great multitude. And even then, when the battle turned, his condition was extremely weak, to the extent that at one point a rumour spread that he had been martyred. And in Medina, the Holy Qur’an says, the hypocrites eagerly spread talk, whispering everywhere, mockery began. Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), took no retaliatory action. Is this called a state of the sword? Then when the Battle of the Confederates took place, the total number of all the Holy Prophet’s (saw) supporters with him is not stated as more than three thousand, and all the Arab tribes surrounded him. The people of Medina withdrew their help. The Jews violated the clear covenant that if any attacker came they would not betray him but would fight alongside him. Far from fighting alongside, they conspired with them and tried to stab him in the back. Then those incidents took place for which … received punishments. So who calls this an Islamic state? Until the Conquest of Mecca the Holy Prophet (saw) was the head of no state, nor did he have any interest in it. And the Conquest of Mecca did not happen by the sword. Which sword conquered Mecca? The order was that the sword not be used. And it is God’s promise: I shall surely be victorious. It is astonishing that the Muslims, whose number only three years earlier totalled no more than three thousand, advanced on Mecca as an army of ten thousand, and the people of Mecca were still the majority. But as the Messenger of God had prophesied: not by fighting, but by the awe of Allah shall I be victorious. Therefore swords were not used, except in one or two exceptional incidents, and Mecca was conquered. After the Conquest of Mecca no one was forced: change your religion or we will kill you. Not a single incident. Therefore this notion in your mind has been wrongly drummed in by some present-day scholars; it is contrary to the dignity of Islam, not in support of it. Present Islam in this way, and it will overcome the world, because with it is the power of its signs and the power of its arguments. And only that message is valued which wins victory over the world by the force of its arguments, not by force, not by the force of the sword. If victories of the sword are the measure, then Communism would have attained even greater superiority than Islam; by force it subjugated more people than Islam ever did. Then acknowledge the dominance of Christianity! Dominance based on sword and power has no truth at all. True dominance is dominance over hearts. And the dominance of Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), the dominance of the Holy Qur’an, was a dominance over hearts – this is our faith. [Questioner: Huzoor, my question was long; my aim was not to prove the sword, but rule, or the enforcement of Islam (Nifaz-e-Islam) by the Holy Prophet…] I am telling you, I have already answered: the Holy Prophet (saw) never enforced Islam by force of the sword – not by the sword, and not by governmental power either. Islam was implemented upon those who had accepted it wholeheartedly. And upon those who had not accepted it, the state could not enforce Islam, because the Holy Qur’an says that they would come and believe in the morning and become apostates in the evening – does it say so or not? So if those people had feared the death penalty for apostasy, what is the Holy Qur’an saying here? Hence there was no compulsion: ‘There is no compulsion in religion.’ There was complete freedom: if you come, come gladly; if you leave, leave gladly; God will hold you to account. Therefore enforcement of Islam simply could not happen by coercion. If one tried to enforce Islam, someone unwilling would say: I am not a Muslim. And who would be so mad as to believe on seeing the strictness of the enforcement of Islam? For the strictness in implementing Islam cannot be accepted by a person unless the heart agrees. The rest of history is tangled, but today’s history is before you, Pakistan: did the state try to enforce Islam there or not? This is yesterday’s event; Zia was still alive. Attempts were made there to enforce Islam by state power. Why did it not happen? Where was it implemented – in Larkana or in some other area, or is Islam being enforced in Karachi nowadays, or in Lahore? Or are incidents of coercion, murder and bloodshed increasing day by day? Do not stay in a world of words; for God’s sake come down, open your eyes and see what is happening. Such enforcement of Islam, or of religion, by coercion cannot possibly endure, and it can never be established. Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), implemented Islam through the path of suffering. He laboured greatly for the reformation of these people; he made them so pure that they staked their lives and did not turn back from faith, gave up everything, relinquished their chieftainships. This is what is called the enforcement of Islam. After this there is no need for coercion; the heart has agreed – as they say, when husband and wife are agreed, what can the Qazi do?

10 of 10 left today