16. My name is Ahmad Khatib Hasid (?). My question, Huzur: why do we not celebrate birthdays?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 May 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My name is Ahmad Khatib Hasid (?). My question, Huzur: why do we not celebrate birthdays?

Why should birthdays be celebrated? Every person is born; it is a chance event, nothing worth a celebration. Most who are born turn out bad: criminals, murderers, oppressors, troublemakers. If most of those born were not like this, the world would be a place of peace. So what is the point of celebrating someone's birthday? If birthdays should be celebrated, who would have the greatest right? The prophets, right? Who are the best people? The prophets of Allah. Their birthdays are not celebrated, no one celebrates them – and if someone does, it is done wrongly and impermissibly. Why? Because the Holy Prophet (saw) never celebrated his birthday himself, nor did his pure wives, nor his children, nor the Companions; and after his demise no one celebrated the birthdays of his Khulafa. In this age no one ever celebrated the birthday of the Promised Messiah (as) – have you ever seen it celebrated? No. Nor was any of his Khulafa's celebrated. Then how can some other child just get up and celebrate a birthday? Is he greater? No, isn't it? So no birthday. Thank you.

10 of 10 left today