19. (Question not preserved in transcript; presumably: why do we not celebrate Christmas?)
Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 May 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Question not preserved in transcript; presumably: why do we not celebrate Christmas?)
We do not celebrate it because Christmas is connected with the Messiah, and we are followers of the Holy Prophet (saw); the beginning of our religion, as it were, starts from the time of the Holy Prophet (saw). Of course all prophets taught the same religion, but if you start celebrating festivities for the earlier prophets too, then back to Hazrat Adam you would have to celebrate one hundred and twenty-four thousand Christmases – what state would you be in! So this much suffices. Secondly, it has already been said that we do not celebrate birthdays at all; we do not celebrate that of the Holy Prophet (saw), so why that of Hazrat Jesus (as)? And Christmas is a birthday. The third answer is that this birthday itself is wrong. Hazrat Jesus (as) was not born on 25 December at all; he was born sometime in September (?), when the date palms still bore fruit. Date palms do not bear fruit in December, and the Holy Qur’an records that it was the season of dates, and the Bible also confirms this. And good researchers, Christian researchers, themselves admit that Christmas is not the birth date of Hazrat Jesus, but the day of an imaginary god called the sun god. Christians attached their day of joy to the day of the sun god, thereby making that day their own, and made a kind of compromise with the polytheists, which was a very impermissible act. For this reason too, even if there were no other reasons, celebrating Christmas is not permissible, because it was really a day for an imaginary god which the Christians hijacked. Understood? Now translate. (Translator in German:) Huzur said that this date is actually not correct, but it was an agreement with unbelievers: a sun god of the unbelievers, and the Christians agreed to celebrate this date although it is not correct.