35. My question is: when we offer prayer, after "wa la d-dallin" we say Amin, but Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim we recite in our heart. Why do we not recite it aloud?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 May 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My question is: when we offer prayer, after "wa la d-dallin" we say Amin, but Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim we recite in our heart. Why do we not recite it aloud?
This has come down in two ways. The Shafi‘is believe that Bismillah should also be recited aloud. And the Hanafi school believes that Bismillah should not be recited aloud, but because it comes before every Surah, it is part of it, and one should recite it in the heart. Since the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat generally follows Hanafi jurisprudence, we also do not recite it aloud. But if someone recites it aloud, we do not forbid it either; that too is permissible. Understood? My maternal uncle, Syed Waliullah Shah Sahib, lived in Arab countries; therefore he learnt there that Bismillah is to be recited aloud, and he recited it aloud all his life. After returning from Arabia nobody stopped him – neither Hazrat Musleh Maud (ra) nor anyone else. So this is not an issue over which fights or debates should be started. If an Ahmadi prefers to recite it aloud, it is permitted. But since we have found this practice that all the Khulafa who passed before recited Bismillah in the heart, I too follow the same way. Understood? But if someone recites it (aloud), I will not call it wrong. Have you understood?