48. My question is: before "Sami‘a llahu liman hamidah" we do not say Allahu Akbar. Why?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 23 May 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My question is: before "Sami‘a llahu liman hamidah" we do not say Allahu Akbar. Why?

Every call given by the imam is a sign that he is now making a movement, and one call is sufficient. The call of Allahu Akbar is given each time, but since there in response to "Sami‘a llahu liman hamidah" people have something to say, "Sami‘a llahu liman hamidah" is the sign that at this point you should say these words. Understood? That is, not everywhere in the prayer is there question and answer. After Allahu Akbar we do say something, but not as an answer; we continue according to each posture. But when "Sami‘a llahu liman hamidah" comes, there is an answer to it: "Rabbana wa laka l-hamd". Therefore on a special occasion a special phrase was taught to us, and at that time there is no need to say Allahu Akbar, because the movement is known from this call. Have you understood?

10 of 10 left today