5. Question from Mr. Malik from Kirkcaldy (North-West/-East?), who lived in Bahrain for a long time: Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib wrote in his early books that Hazrat Jesus (as) was raised to heaven; later he believed that he had died and that Mirza Sahib himself was the Promised Messiah. Please explain this contradiction.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 June 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Question from Mr. Malik from Kirkcaldy (North-West/-East?), who lived in Bahrain for a long time: Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib wrote in his early books that Hazrat Jesus (as) was raised to heaven; later he believed that he had died and that Mirza Sahib himself was the Promised Messiah. Please explain this contradiction.
(Before that, a brief remark on the place name: it should be “Bahrain” – between two seas or a similar place; there is sea on all sides, but I don’t quite understand the word in Arabic; it may be Bahrain.)
This is not a contradiction; rather it is in fact a sign of his piety and truthfulness. Every prophet who is born does not make plans from childhood to become a prophet. He grows up like ordinary children; only goodness is evident in him, nothing more. When God appoints him, He (God) abrogates the earlier ideas; he does not do so on his own. Thus, regarding Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), it is a definitive, accepted fact that as long as no specific revelation came to him about the law, he acted upon the earlier law and did not abandon the earlier beliefs. He also kept the Qibla towards Bait-ul-Maqdis, though in his heart he longed that the Qibla be changed to the place of Abraham, to his place of prayer. Keeping to old beliefs and considering them, irrespective of whether they are correct or not, is also a sign of piety. Until God clarifies, one’s gaze does not turn from these things, cannot turn away. So just as the change of Qibla took place, a change of Qibla took place in this matter for Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as). He had heard from the Mullahs, generation after generation, that the Messiah is alive, and accepted it. But when God told him, and also pointed out to him in the Holy Qur’an which verses bear witness to it, and when the verses became witnesses and he presented them, his change did not come from personal inclination but was strengthened by the content of the Holy Qur’an. That is why such things are not called a contradiction. Thank you.