6. Question from Ms. Tahira Younis from Clapham, a non-Ahmadi lady (present): Why are Ahmadis not accepted as Muslims? If Ahmadis are Muslims, how can I know that they are Muslims?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 June 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Question from Ms. Tahira Younis from Clapham, a non-Ahmadi lady (present): Why are Ahmadis not accepted as Muslims? If Ahmadis are Muslims, how can I know that they are Muslims?

Very good, Masha’Allah. Why Ahmadis are not accepted as Muslims – the Mullahs could answer that; I do accept them, so you have asked the wrong man. But in a sense it is right: she knows that I would know, and she has trusted me to tell the truth. So I answer from the angle of why the Mullahs declare us non-Muslims.

First: if the doctrine of Khatam-e-Nubuwwat, as I explained earlier, is wrongly interpreted, and it is said that the Holy Qur’an says there is no prophet after him, the Messenger of Allah (saw) says “La nabiyya ba’di,” and after that a man begins a new line of prophethood – how can he remain a Muslim? He who has broken the seal of prophethood, who has claimed freedom from servitude to the Messenger of Allah (saw), is a Kafir, and his followers too. And one thing they do not tell you, I will tell you: by this they too would become Kafir; all would be in it together. For they themselves believe that the Messiah will come and the Mahdi will also come, and they believe the Messiah will necessarily be a Prophet of Allah. So the difference is only of identity; in doctrine no difference remains. All these scholars accept – ask them – that when the Messiah comes he will be a Prophet of Allah; that God will appoint the Imam Mahdi – they say He certainly will. If you reject God’s Imam Mahdi, how can you accept the Messiah? The question does not arise. When we say the same thing, we are Kafir? They don’t become Kafir. If it is poison, everyone has eaten it; then it should be collective suicide. But we escape in this way: their own conduct and position declares them false. So if anyone becomes non-Muslim, it is they, not we.

And what authority do I have? That of the Messenger of Allah (saw). There are two fatwas of the Holy Prophet (saw) to keep in view. First: if anyone declares a Muslim a Kafir, he himself becomes a Kafir. The scholars know this fatwa is authentic, and no one will argue that it is a weak Hadith. Before calling them Kafir, Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) bore their fatwas patiently for twelve years continuously and reminded them of these Hadiths. He said: I do not want to call anyone who recites the Kalima a Kafir; even if you reject me, I do not have it in me to call a reciter of the Kalima a Kafir. But I am telling you this Hadith: if you do not desist, no one can give a fatwa against the fatwa of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw). And after the warning, after twelve years of patience, after enduring abuse and being called Kafir and Dajjal, when they did not desist, he then gave this fatwa. And such was his patience: Hazrat Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan Sahib, who became an Ahmadi from the Shia and was a follower of Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as), despite being an Ahmadi kept Maulvi Sana’ullah employed in his home, and he was the prayer leader; they offered prayers behind Maulvi Sana’ullah. So not only was magnanimity claimed, it was openly visible. Who can say anything against these facts? If any descendants of Maulvi Sana’ullah are alive, ask them: their father was employed by our uncle Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan, also for the children’s education, and was also the Imam. When these Mullahs did not desist, then this fatwa of Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) was issued: now I have no room left; if you call me Kafir, according to the fatwa of the Messenger of Allah (saw) you will become Kafir. That is one answer from our side.

Beyond this, I put before you another decisive argument, and you, the lady, will be amazed that they have no option but to honestly admit themselves to be false. This Hadith they themselves have been telling the Ummah and still speak of: the Messenger of Allah (saw) said a time will come when my Ummah, like the Jews, will split into 72 sects. This is the Hadith which Maulvi Abdul Wahhab Sahib, head of the Wahhabi sect, presented with great emphasis as a sign of his truthfulness: the Messenger of Allah (saw) said it would split into 72 sects, all 72 will be in Hell, except one, which will be the 73rd Jamaat. Maulvi Abdul Wahhab Sahib claimed – it is written in his books – that the sect of which he is the founder is that 73rd Jamaat for which there was the glad tiding that they are true Muslims and dwellers of Paradise, while all the other 72 are in Hell. And this was fully accepted in Saudi Arabia. Now tell me: they let the 72 “Hell” sects perform Hajj, and have expelled only one – the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Strange, isn’t it? The Messenger of Allah (saw) says 72 will be in Hell, one in Paradise, and that will be a Jamaat; and their own founder says we are that Jamaat. So the rest became dwellers of Hell – yet for these dwellers of Hell the doors are open, shrine visits are arranged for them, all facilities for Hajj are being provided, and the one which is a Jamaat – the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat – is thrown out.

Now the argument takes another form. Perhaps they are all truthful in the sense that each thinks it is the 73rd; each has that right. If we have the right, they have it too. If they have the right to consider themselves the 73rd and the rest the 72, what are they doing sitting among the 72? Why don’t they declare among them: you are by no means Muslims, you are dwellers of Hell? When the declaration comes, they say: we 72 on one side, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat on the other. And when they claim to be true, they say: we are the 73rd Jamaat – while sitting among the 72. Tell me: in a hotel with 72 rooms, if fire breaks out in the 72, will the occupants of the 73rd room remain sitting, included among them? Everyone will try to get out. The Messenger of Allah (saw) spoke of fire, so the 72 caught fire, i.e. became misguided, and these sit inside proudly saying: we are among the 72. Thus their gathering together against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat confirms that they are the 72. And when they are part of the 72, the fatwa of the Messenger of Allah (saw) will apply; their claim will be of no use. This is a clear-cut matter. If you reflect on it, I hope, Insha’Allah, you will understand why they call us non-Muslims. Therein lies the proof of their falsehood: why don’t they call each other non-Muslims? When you claim to be the 73rd – what else is a non-Muslim than those whom the Messenger of Allah (saw) called dwellers of Hell? No one says it; there their voices are muted. They are cowards, have no piety, play politics – what other purpose is there? Look at the fatwas the Sunnis have issued against the Shias, and the Shias’ counter-fatwas are very harsh – but there at Hajj no one objects to them. There too the sect arose in the name of Tauhid, and all the shrines that were revered were demolished, all signs of veneration removed. Yet Barelwis also come there in hundreds of thousands, who even prostrate before Data Darbar, who have set up Pirs everywhere, on whose trees they tie rags, scraps of cloth, as tokens: from this Pir we asked for a son, he gave it; by that Pir we had our cold cured, he cured it. Such trees abound in Hazara, with colourful rags hanging on them. Such idolaters they permit and raise no objection. It is politics, nothing else. Their fatwa is just like their conduct.

(Someone hands over a reference.) Ah, Nawa-e-Waqt; I have been given the reference I wanted to mention but did not have with me. I had in mind: when the decision against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat was made that the National Assembly of Pakistan, in which representatives of all sects were present, unanimously decided that all these are Muslims and only the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is outside the fold of Islam, this decision was announced in Nawa-e-Waqt, Lahore, of 16 October 1974 in these words: “The solution of the Qadiani issue and some interesting facts … A special significance of this decision is that a genuine consensus of the Ummah (Ijma’) was reached on it. In the entire history of Islam there has never been such complete consensus on any important issue. In this consensus, besides the greatest religious scholars of the country and the bearers of the clear Shari’a, all political leaders and the political leaders of every group fully agreed, and the honoured Sufis, the knowers of God and the elect of Sufism and Tariqa were also in full agreement. Leaving aside the Qadiani sect, all the 72 sects said to be those of the Muslims are agreed and pleased with the solution of this issue.” Now tell me: have they accepted being the 72 or not? They have. Will they now apply their own fatwa, or will the fatwa of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), apply? They have accepted being the 72, and we agree; but over the 72 only the fatwa of the Messenger of Allah (saw) will apply. That is why, before this decision, our Imam at the time, Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh), sitting in the National Assembly, referring to this, warned them: see, you obtained this government in the name of God, by reciting the Kalima of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw); do not collectively rebel against the decision of the Holy Prophet (saw). You have the right that each of your sects says: we are the Jamaat, the rest are the 72; but you do not have the right to call yourselves the 72 and also declare yourselves dwellers of Paradise. After hearing this warning, this announcement was made. Now decide for yourself.

10 of 10 left today