1. My question is: if a person denies the Hadith, how can the truth of the claim of the Promised Messiah (as) be proven in the light of the Holy Qur’an?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 August 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My question is: if a person denies the Hadith, how can the truth of the claim of the Promised Messiah (as) be proven in the light of the Holy Qur’an?
This question has two aspects. If he denies the Hadith, then he is not truly convinced of the Holy Qur’an either. That is the first problem. He must first be convinced of the Holy Qur’an, in the sense that there are verses of the Holy Qur’an which shed light on the Hadith and prove the need for the Hadith. Without understanding them the matter cannot be complete. For the fact is that even if the Holy Qur’an is presented, different people give different meanings to its verses, and a single verse has various meanings even in our commentaries. So the denier of Hadith faces this problem: he says, you gave this meaning, I give that meaning. Then even the Holy Qur’an is not sufficient for him. Whoever separates the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith is unfortunate, because the Holy Qur’an itself states that a person who makes a distinction between Allah and His Messenger is not among the believers. Now the question is, who is the one making the distinction? For example, the Holy Qur’an says: Obey Allah and the Messenger. Obedience to Allah is understood; the Holy Qur’an is the word of Allah. What then is obedience to the Messenger? If the Hadith has no existence, if the Sunnah has no authority, then what is that obedience which is obedience to the Messenger? Why would God use superfluous words in His eloquent speech? It would have been enough to say: Obey Allah. And if a difference, a dispute arises within the Ummah, between government and people, the Holy Qur’an says: ‘And if you dispute about anything, refer it to Allah and His Messenger…’ [gap in recording] …he would have been limited to his time and offered no solution for future disputes – that would be the result. But if future disputes are in view, then obedience to Allah will be found in the Holy Qur’an; how will you present the dispute before the Messenger? Therefore the discussion should start from the fundamental issue. Otherwise we may draw as many arguments from the Holy Qur’an as we like, the Ahl-e-Qur’an will keep saying: No, I am not convinced, I understand it to mean this. If the Hadith confirms it and a person is convinced of the Hadith with reasoning, then no way out remains for him. Therefore everyone must first be made to understand according to his intellect and circumstances, otherwise talking to him is useless. My experience with the Ahl-e-Qur’an is exactly this: present a hundred thousand arguments from the Holy Qur’an, they say: No, we understand it this way, and there is no one whose word we accept as the meaning of the Holy Qur’an. So the Holy Qur’an, which they call the basis of unity, they practically turn into a cause of disunity. This too is why the coming of a spiritual authority is necessary. The concept of the Imam Mahdi also means that when differences arise in the nation, the one guided by Allah will be authorised by God to decide the differences as well. That is why in the Ahadith – leave the deniers of Hadith aside for now, you do not appear to be a denier of Hadith – in the Ahadith the words ‘Hakam and ‘Adl’ (arbiter and just) are clearly used about both the Messiah and the Mahdi. Why will they come? They will sit on the seat of judgement amid their differences and decide who is right according to the Holy Qur’an and who is wrong according to the Holy Qur’an, who is right according to the Hadith and who is wrong according to the Hadith. So, using the name of the Holy Qur’an, they outwardly say: the basis of unity is the Holy Qur’an, leave the Ahadith and you will be united. Yet when they come to the Holy Qur’an without Hadith, they do not unite even on the meaning of a single verse. So it is merely an excuse of the ego. And was the grace of the Holy Prophet (saw) limited only to the period he lived in this world? What then does being a Messenger until the Day of Judgement mean? The Book could have descended by itself; people did demand that a ready-made book should descend. But without the Messenger the reality of the Book cannot be known. Without the Messenger acting upon the Book is not even possible. What are the prayers, what are the details of worship? Where in the Holy Qur’an are the details? What we saw Hazrat Muhammad (saw) doing, how he understood the Holy Qur’an – by acting accordingly we received the grace of the Holy Qur’an. Therefore to obtain the grace of the Holy Qur’an without the grace of the one to whom the Holy Qur’an was given is a deceptive claim; there is no truth in it. There will be other questions now. If you wish to repeat this question in another way – show the claim from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith together – then I will speak on that.