1. Why is it necessary to look at the place of prostration while praying, and why is it disliked (makruh) to close the eyes?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 4 September 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Why is it necessary to look at the place of prostration while praying, and why is it disliked (makruh) to close the eyes?

Have you kept your eyes open towards me or not? Why don't you close them? When you talk to me you don't do it like that, because your inner self tells you that it is not appropriate to stand with closed eyes before the one you are speaking to. And the Holy Prophet (saw) said that one should practise Ihsan in prayer. The definition of Ihsan is: feel as if you are standing before God and seeing God; and if not that, then at least see that God is seeing you. Therefore it is a condition that the eyes be kept open and that one not speak with closed eyes. Secondly, closed eyes also produce heedlessness, a kind of drowsiness or a state of inattention sets in. With open eyes a person speaks consciously. The other point is the gaze towards the place of prostration: etiquette requires both that the eyes are not closed and that one does not speak raising the gaze, meeting eye to eye. And naturally, wherever reverence prevails, a person's gaze lowers. That is why the Holy Prophet (saw) said: keep your gaze on the place of prostration. Another aspect of wisdom is that if the gaze stays raised, people coming and going far in front of you will keep pulling your attention; those passing from right and left and in front, leaving the place of prostration clear, will keep diverting your attention elsewhere. But if the gaze is on the place of prostration, even if someone passes a little further away, your attention will not go there; it will remain focused on the place of prostration and your prayer will not be disturbed. These are the possibilities that have arisen in my mind, that the Holy Prophet (saw) must have said this in view of these wisdoms. All right?

10 of 10 left today