10. Allah says in Surah As-Sajdah: 'And if We had pleased, We could have given every soul its guidance, but the word from Me has come true …' Did Allah Himself intend all this to happen this way? And: the believers were not overcome, but they were made to suffer so much – what then?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 4 September 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Allah says in Surah As-Sajdah: 'And if We had pleased, We could have given every soul its guidance, but the word from Me has come true …' Did Allah Himself intend all this to happen this way? And: the believers were not overcome, but they were made to suffer so much – what then?

[On the recitation:] 'kulla nafsin', not 'kullu'. You have not read the whole Holy Qur’an. There Allah has stated concerning mercy that it is for this very reason that We created man, to show him mercy. There are two reasons why some receive God's mercy and some punishment. The philosophy for those who receive punishment He explained elsewhere in the Holy Qur’an: We had laid both paths open to them; if they wished they would choose the path of truth, if they wished the path of evil, of falsehood. Whatever path one chose, God dealt with him accordingly. This is the scheme of things, the philosophy of 'haqqa l-qaul': this word of God had necessarily to come true, that Hell would be filled with those who accept evil; and also that word of God came true which He said to Satan in opposition: over My servants you will have no dominion. So it is a scheme on both sides. [Objection: dominion was not achieved, but they were made to suffer so much.] That proves he did not prevail. Listen and stay calm. Had no suffering been inflicted, how would their truthfulness have been manifested, what trial would it have been? If you are called to a meal and you come, how is your truthfulness proven? If you are hungry, your life ebbing away, and you give your food to someone else, then your truthfulness is shown. God gave Satan free rein: bring as many calamities on My servants as you like, bring your foot soldiers, charge with your horsemen, attack with all your strength – even then you will not be able to shake them. It is the very sufferings that are the sign of their truthfulness. [Questioner: According to a hadith …] Enough. You have a habit of arguing; I will not argue. What I have explained is sufficient. If you did not understand, so be it, because every time you ask you insist like this; it has become your way. Everyone understood this simple matter of common sense except you. So either don't ask questions or quietly go back with the answer I give – whether your heart is satisfied or not, I am not responsible. Allah is the Master.

10 of 10 left today