8. … this is the case with many people: they have pets such as dogs. When they are invited to our home, they bring their dogs along. We are afraid of them and consider them impure, but this affects relations badly. Huzur, we would like to know more about this. One solution is to befriend the dogs as well, because these people do not accept that the dog is an impure animal.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 October 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: … this is the case with many people: they have pets such as dogs. When they are invited to our home, they bring their dogs along. We are afraid of them and consider them impure, but this affects relations badly. Huzur, we would like to know more about this. One solution is to befriend the dogs as well, because these people do not accept that the dog is an impure animal.
I have already given the answer. Where have you heard that a dog is pure or impure? Some dogs are impure, some are not. It depends on how they are kept. Where people themselves are impure, the dogs are even more impure. (Brief interruption about the sound.) The problem with dogs is keeping them without purpose, in areas where dogs are generally not cared for and they make filth everywhere. Untrained dogs are a nuisance. They make every place impure, sit wherever they like, urinate wherever they like, do whatever they like. When such dogs enter a house, the situation is such that angels will then not come there. By angels are meant righteous people, and other angels can also be meant who come on occasions of worship. Where instead of dogs children are kept in houses in such a way that there is urine everywhere and stench rises, angels will not come there either. They are not 'allergic' only to dogs' urine; they are allergic to every filth. So one should understand the meaning. What the Holy Prophet (saw) said about dogs, he said in this sense. Whereas the Holy Qur’an has also mentioned the history of some dogs and mentioned the dog of the Companions of the Cave, that it was such a loyal animal that it constantly sat at the mouth of their cave for protection. The love for dogs in Christian nations did not arise by chance; generation after generation, through old historical events, it has been absorbed into their blood. The dog was loyal to them and served them for a long time. Now these nations are loyal to the dog, and the dog still serves them. This is a purposeful thing. The Holy Qur’an has permitted the dog for hunting. If it were impure, would the Holy Qur’an permit you to eat prey killed by the dog's mouth? Every hunting animal, whether falcon or dog, that has been trained, over which Bismillah was said before releasing it – the animal it catches is permissible according to the Holy Qur’an even if it dies before you reach it. Because it is wounded, the blood flows, and you released the dog or falcon after saying Bismillah, so the animal it caught has become lawful for you. Now tell me: if they were impure in the sense people generally think, how would Bismillah work over that impure thing in the first place? And then the animal it seizes with its mouth – while the Holy Qur’an says that eating what is left over by beasts of prey is forbidden – becomes permissible there, because an animal has been properly trained with skill and order for the task. Benefiting from that is not forbidden. So keeping dogs without purpose is not appropriate. In our countries dogs are not trained. Where there are dogs, they are mostly tied up outside; they do not even know what is inside the house. That is also why only the rich keep dogs, who make space for them outside. But if dogs are trained so that they move around inside the house and make no filth, and go out when they need to urinate – with these people's dogs it is like this: if they have a need, they bark, but never soil the place, so that someone gets up and opens the door; they go out, relieve themselves at their spot and come back. So dogs have many good qualities too, which should be remembered. Humans urinate and get splashed; the Holy Prophet (saw) strictly warned against this. But look at the dog: it urinates against a wall or a tree so that the splashes do not fall on it. And whenever it drops excrement somewhere, it tries to bury it with its paws, to cover it. But walk around in Pakistan, in the markets …, where tea is being served and food distributed, look a little to the side: everything is full of dirt and filth, so much filth that one finds no space. That is how nations are: a nation whose filth is in such a state, its dogs are the same. The poor creatures wander around mangy, a terrible sight. Therefore filth is the real thing to be avoided. People do not understand this and throw stones at dogs. The love for dogs of those who have come close to us here is meaningful, but that does not mean they all keep their dogs clean. Some people's dogs lie in their beds and make filth everywhere, and the whole house is full of stench. So the purpose of the statement is not that every dog everywhere among them is kept clean. Some, however, are kept so clean, shined, groomed daily, that no aspect of dirt or smell is visible. If such people bring their dogs, then gather up the place where you pray and lock your room where you pray. Explain to them that these are certain places where we worship and their cleanliness is necessary. They do not take dogs to church either – they will understand immediately: yes, that is right. If their dog behaves decently, let it move around. If you are afraid, that is another matter – fear cannot be removed by my advice.