19. Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. My name is Ataur Rahman (?). I have a small question: If four or five people live together in one house, and one is an Ahmadi and the rest are non-Ahmadis, can one offer the congregational prayer with them, with their imam leading, or should one offer one’s prayer alone?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 October 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. My name is Ataur Rahman (?). I have a small question: If four or five people live together in one house, and one is an Ahmadi and the rest are non-Ahmadis, can one offer the congregational prayer with them, with their imam leading, or should one offer one’s prayer alone?
(Huzur asks:) Does he deny the Promised Messiah (as)? (Questioner: No.) Does he deny the truthfulness of the Promised Messiah (as)? (Questioner: No, he is a non-Ahmadi.) He does not deny and he is not an Ahmadi either – how can that be? If he does not deny, why is he not an Ahmadi? (Questioner: No, Huzur, he does not do it in front of us.) It is not a matter of what happens in front of you. It is a very plain matter. Do not bend your own self in his favour. You know that he is not an Ahmadi because he considers the Promised Messiah (as) a liar. Can it be that someone considers the Promised Messiah (as) to be the Imam Mahdi, acknowledges him as the Imam appointed by God, and then is not an Ahmadi? It can be [in rare cases]. You know it, whether he says it or not. The Christians do not consider the Holy Prophet (saw) truthful. They do not go around everywhere announcing that the Holy Prophet (saw) – God forbid – is a liar, a liar, a liar. They then come with decency; civility demands it, so they do not call him a liar. Will you then say: pray behind a Christian, after all he does not call him a liar? His belief shows that the Holy Prophet (saw) – God forbid – is not truthful. The belief of every non-Ahmadi shows that he considers the Promised Messiah (as) – God forbid – to be one who fabricates lies against Allah and a liar. Until he declares: this is wrong, I consider him truthful – whether he then takes the Bai’at or not, that will not be debated – but this declaration is necessary, and without hypocrisy, not only before his own people. He should say before everyone: I consider the Promised Messiah (as) truthful; because of the world I do not have the strength to take the Bai’at, but I consider him truthful. Then you may certainly pray behind him. But this declaration is necessary. Otherwise your condition would be far worse than hypocrisy. For here is a person who denies the Promised Messiah (as), whom God Almighty has appointed and who claims: I have been made your Imam by God – he denies this Imam made by God. And you do not have the courage to reject a self-made imam. Is this humanity? Such cowardice, that the other person with great courage and boldness denies the Imam made by God, and you say: I will pray behind you, you are my imam. How then will that Imam whom God has made remain your Imam? It is a small matter, a matter of common sense. Therefore there is no need here for any compromise or for any change in order to please someone.