21. Assalamu alaikum. Huzur, my question is: After death, when the human soul receives a new body, and that person has some good deeds and some bad, is the process of reward and punishment applied to that body simultaneously, or does that body endure suffering as punishment for a fixed period and then go to the place of reward?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 October 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Assalamu alaikum. Huzur, my question is: After death, when the human soul receives a new body, and that person has some good deeds and some bad, is the process of reward and punishment applied to that body simultaneously, or does that body endure suffering as punishment for a fixed period and then go to the place of reward?
Your question is rather tangled. You mean that first he will be punished and then forgiven – that is one form. If he is punished, then he has not been forgiven. Once he has entered the phase of reward and punishment, being punished means he has not been forgiven. For if the punishment has been given, has begun, then at the time of resurrection, when his body is raised again, it is a punished body that will rise. Have you understood? And what is to happen to him at that time begins after death. Your question is like a child that is sick in its mother’s womb, and you ask whether the illness will suddenly be cured after birth. How will it be cured? One whose very constitution contains the illness will remain ill after birth too. Likewise, if God wishes to forgive, it is as if the child in the mother’s womb is made healthy; then it is saved, then it is born healthy. So the soul which in the intermediate world (Barzakh), in the state before the second life in which it will be raised, has seen the winds of torment – after death and also at the time of rising, its development is taking place in that very state. Therefore it is wrong to assume that there will be a separate forgiveness later. When God decides on forgiveness, then Allah the Almighty treats him with gentleness already within his phase of development. All right?