2. The second question is from Mr Darshan Singh Grewal, general secretary of the Transport and Workers' Union. [He asks the question himself; only this is discernible:] … what we as workers undertake [strikes] – is this considered legitimate in Islam?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 December 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The second question is from Mr Darshan Singh Grewal, general secretary of the Transport and Workers' Union. [He asks the question himself; only this is discernible:] … what we as workers undertake [strikes] – is this considered legitimate in Islam?
As far as Islamic countries or the common religious scholars are concerned, this question has no significance at all for them. Let people do it, they do not care; they themselves strike and they themselves stage sit-ins. But as far as the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat understands Islamic teaching, according to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat there is no need for strike action. There are two points. First, a strike shows that the government is neglecting its duties. The sensitivity should lie with the government, that it should come down and keep an eye on needs, and if the needs are legitimate, fulfil them without being asked. And if they are not legitimate, then whether it is a strike or anything else, the government should not yield to it, because principle demands that one not submit to wrongful pressure in a wrong matter. Therefore in Islam, in Islamic teaching, there is no occasion for a strike at all. There is definite testimony about Hazrat Umar (ra) that during his Khilafat, night after night, he would take his servant and walk about in such clothing that ordinary passers-by would not recognise him, and he would go out late, deep in the night, and make rounds to see whether anyone was in distress. He would pass by houses, and if a painful cry came from inside, if someone was in distress, he would immediately try himself to remedy it. Now it is not possible in this age for every head of state personally to make rounds of every street of large countries. But God has also given facilities to the same extent. Today the system of surveillance has advanced so far that, sitting at home, people find out the inner affairs of whole families – those who do it with ill intent. But if, with good intent, modern methods were used to keep watch on public needs, and news were obtained moment by moment, this is not impossible. Therefore the principle is the same: the government should be sensitive towards those people over whom it is a guardian. That is why the Holy Qur’an has presented a concept of government that is completely different from that of the ordinary mullahs or others. The Holy Qur’an says: 'And when you judge between people, judge with justice.' Allah commands you that when you govern people, with what should you govern? With the Shariah, with the Holy Qur’an, with the Granth Sahib or with the Vedas? There is no mention of this. 'That you judge with justice' – govern with justice alone. No religion, no other system should be before you, neither party politics nor any other motives, but complete justice, absolute justice. Other than this there is no system of government that the Holy Qur’an presents. And if there is absolute justice, then nothing else is needed, nothing at all. All protests in fact arise as a result of the absence of justice. Therefore, as I said, it is the duty of the government: if justice has not been done to someone, the government will be answerable. This is the second point, which compels an Islamic government, if it is a true Islamic government, to establish such conditions that the public never needs to protest. The second concept God Almighty has presented, in the Holy Qur’an as well as in Hadith, is that you are answerable for your deeds. And the Holy Prophet (saw) went so far as to say that every head of a household is answerable to God for the family under his care. He is not the owner, he is a trustee; he holds trusts. Just as every shepherd is answerable for sheep whose owners are others, so every person is answerable for those under him. Expanding this theme, he also mentions government: every ruler will be questioned about his subjects. So where this system is established, the question of a strike does not even arise. It is the reverse: such governments become so beloved that people lay down their lives for them. All right.