8. (Question from Mrs Nasira Nasreen Shukla of Tooting, an Ahmadi lady converted from Hinduism:) What does Islam say about surrogate mothers? Does Islam permit it? Recently it was on TV that a mother bore a child for her daughter.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 December 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Question from Mrs Nasira Nasreen Shukla of Tooting, an Ahmadi lady converted from Hinduism:) What does Islam say about surrogate mothers? Does Islam permit it? Recently it was on TV that a mother bore a child for her daughter.

I submit: Islam has laid down clear laws for preserving human lineage, as every religion does. The central purpose of these laws is to protect the children born of husband and wife and to prevent the offspring of someone else from mixing with them. There is the concept of ‘walad-ul-haram’, i.e. illegitimate children; not only Islam but every religion tries to prevent this and teaches accordingly. What you call a surrogate mother – give it whatever name you like – in practice means that a man not married to that woman had his sperm introduced into her womb through scientists, trampling the sanctity of marriage. The form you describe is especially horrible: that one’s own mother-in-law was in practice made a means of bearing children. The reason: even if the mother’s egg is transferred – I know the scientists’ point that surrogate mother does not necessarily mean the man’s sperm is joined directly with her ovum; the ovum belongs to the mother, it is fertilised and transferred into another woman’s womb – yet scientists familiar with the subject say most characteristics come not from the ovum but from the nurturing in the womb: during that time it receives blood, substances of every kind of defence system reach it, the child receives them from her. So it is wrong to say it is not the child of the mother in whose womb it developed; it is more the child of her from whose womb it was born than of the other mother. And the psychological and emotional bond that arises is stronger in the mother who gave birth. That is why some mothers in America have taken back their children through lawsuits: they gave us money in the name of surrogacy – to hell with the money, give us back our child, we cannot live without it. So in practice the laws for the upbringing and development of children, or for protecting human life, are being bypassed; they want to bypass them, coming by another route and presenting a way that is in no way permissible and is harmful from a human point of view too. Thus in many such cases that I looked into, the main argument in favour of the surrogate mother has been that psychologically and in terms of blood relation this mother has a much greater right to the child and a much stronger natural bond with it than the egg-mother, who only provided the egg, nothing more. Therefore this is entirely impermissible.

10 of 10 left today