12. The Mahzarnama states on page 20 roughly that no person or sect is authorised to declare anyone outside the Muslim Ummah; this relationship is between God and man and will be decided on the Day of Judgement. This is a clear and reasoned statement. Why, then, did Hazrat Mirza Nasir Ahmad (rh) in 1974 have to appear before the National Assembly when this was written so clearly in the Mahzarnama?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 December 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The Mahzarnama states on page 20 roughly that no person or sect is authorised to declare anyone outside the Muslim Ummah; this relationship is between God and man and will be decided on the Day of Judgement. This is a clear and reasoned statement. Why, then, did Hazrat Mirza Nasir Ahmad (rh) in 1974 have to appear before the National Assembly when this was written so clearly in the Mahzarnama?
[Partial gap] ... this Mahzarnama – scholars were also appointed, but in practice almost all of it I wrote with my own hand. Although every person has the right to consider another to be in error, and no one can take this right from him, whoever believes so may not impose it on the other, that he too should consider himself in error; that is unreasonable. For example, someone calls another a dog ... [gap]. I had raised this question: you call us non-Muslims ... [gap]. That was the argument to be presented, and I thought it had become clear; but it seems it did not become fully clear. However, in the later discussion it was made clear – I remember speaking in detail with Pirzada Sahib about this; I said: you have the right that Shias may consider Sunnis non-Muslims or outside Islam – if not, why was it used? – yet Shias have never deprived non-Shia Muslims of the right to recite the Kalima because we consider you non-Muslims, or of the right to pray because we consider you non-Muslims. That is the detail of the argument. Now as to why he appeared, whether it was a weakness: had it been a weakness, he would never have appeared. A brave wrestler who is fully certain that even if the whole world questions and cross-examines him, they cannot defeat him – only such a one can accept this invitation. [Gap] Hazrat (rh) presented himself continuously for ... days: ask what you will, any kind of question, I am ready. And had they made a decision based on those questions, on his failure to answer, I can prove to you right now that the decision now made could not have been made. The reason: if you get the chance to read the proceedings – the maulvis have published one with cuts and additions, that is a false record, the original is something else – if you can study it, or ask the members of the Assembly still living: not once did either the government’s counsel or the maulvis raise the issue of the finality of prophethood (Khatm-e-Nubuwwat), not once. The reason is that in that very Mahzarnama [gap] ... no question at all was asked about the Ahmadi understanding of the finality of prophethood with reference to the Holy Qur’an or Hadith, and yet the conclusion was drawn that they deny the finality of prophethood. The questions were irrelevant; that is, the knee is struck and the eye bursts – how can that be? Hence it is proven that the position Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh) had presented was strong, reasoned and powerful. And the last thing I want to tell you: there are living witnesses to this, not just one, there will be several, but one witness in particular is still alive [gap] ... Mian Farooq Ali Sahib (?); he too knows, and many know; whether they admit it or not is up to them. When this debate or cross-examination came to an end, MNAs themselves came to me to congratulate, since I knew most of them more or less, and said: congratulations, our consensus of opinion is that the maulvis have been left with nothing, you have won. If you want testimony for this, the greatest testimony is that of Mufti Mahmud. He says: my nights ... [gap] ... that you dare not decide in favour of the Ahmadis; if you do, I will throw you like dogs before the followers of these maulvis, and whatever they do to you, you will then be responsible. An MNA himself told me this later as well: until yesterday we were telling you something else, today a different decision has been made; we apologise, we did not have the strength to stand up to the government, especially to this threat of Bhutto Sahib. This is the true state of affairs. There is no question of cowardice in it, nor of any failure.