3. (Question in Punjabi, poorly audible) I am Harchan Singh ... Guru Baba Nanak went to Mecca ... What is your view on this?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 February 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Question in Punjabi, poorly audible) I am Harchan Singh ... Guru Baba Nanak went to Mecca ... What is your view on this?
There are two testimonies about Baba Sahib: one, that he went to Mecca; the other, that he also went to Benares and other major centres of the Hindus. Right? But there is a difference: it is not established that he worshipped in a temple like the Hindus; whoever says so makes a false accusation, for he believed in the Oneness of God. But it is established that he offered prayers in Mecca and performed the Hajj. This shows that going to Mecca is one thing and visiting shrines is another. He went there to deliver the message of the Oneness of God, and when he performed the obligations of Muslims in Mecca, it shows that he was a chosen saint of Allah and a Muslim. There is an incident in your traditions which those who do not want Guru Baba Nanak to be accepted as a Muslim saint present as an argument that he was not a saint but had a new religion of his own. They relate that he was sitting with his legs towards the Ka'bah; a custodian came, stopped him and said this was not proper. Thereupon, whichever way he turned his legs, the Ka'bah ... This has entered the literature. If you take it as true: the Ka'bah is the sign of God's Oneness, and a great blemish would fall on Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak, as if Allah's Oneness lay under his feet. Either it is a vision to show that the Ka'bah is in fact a manifestation of God and God is everywhere; whichever way you turn your legs, God will be there. This is what the Holy Qur’an likewise says in connection with the Ka'bah: whichever way you turn, there is God. Since this accords with the content of the Holy Qur’an, I interpret it thus: this scene would have been shown to make that man understand that this is a person whose wisdom you do not grasp. But his reverence for the Ka'bah is established. Is it established even once that he wore, say, the Gita or the Vedas as an amulet around his neck? But what you call 'Pothi Sharif' is the Holy Qur’an. ... (gap in audio) ... the fruits which he offered to the Oneness of God; the fruits he received were fruits of God's Oneness. Muslims too stayed with him in the same way in his dervish fellowship; you know the name Bhai Mardana. It is clearly evident that he was a holy Sufi ... were sensitive about someone apostatising. But there is not a single incident of anyone accusing the Muslim followers of Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak of having abandoned their faith. This whole history is such open testimony that, in my view, you should accept it. The conflicts did not arise in the time of Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak; they were political conflicts in the time of Aurangzeb. Because the Mughal Empire wanted to consolidate its rule over Punjab, it began harassing the Sikhs. The result was that they began to drift away, and since the ruler was a Muslim, they came into conflict with the Muslims. So it was a political war that changed the religion. That is my impression. Thank you. (While the next questioner was being called, Huzur added:) Regarding oppression: we do not endorse Aurangzeb's cruelties against the Sikhs, but Islam is not at fault in this. A Sikh who held a special position on the Gurdwara committee there said this; for the first time his reply delighted me, he gave a very good answer. Someone raised the point: have you not seen what cruelty Aurangzeb committed, have you forgotten it, and as a Sikh you keep relations with Muslims? He said: he has not considered what that man did to his father and brothers. Someone who was like that to his own father and brothers, how could he have been otherwise to you? Was that a religious conflict with his brothers?