6. (After personal words of thanks: a mountain of grief had fallen upon me, I asked Huzur for prayers at ten at night, and the result is miraculous; not only my face but my heart too is cheerful, Alhamdulillah.) Huzur, I am in great difficulty. God is the Ruler, Wise, All-Knowing and Everlasting. In the Holy Qur’an and according to the general belief of Muslims, man has been a monotheist since the beginning of creation, and since Allah made humans human He created the means of their guidance. But all archaeological research to date has clearly shown that early man was not a monotheist but a polytheist. This is a contradiction for which I seek a solution.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 February 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (After personal words of thanks: a mountain of grief had fallen upon me, I asked Huzur for prayers at ten at night, and the result is miraculous; not only my face but my heart too is cheerful, Alhamdulillah.) Huzur, I am in great difficulty. God is the Ruler, Wise, All-Knowing and Everlasting. In the Holy Qur’an and according to the general belief of Muslims, man has been a monotheist since the beginning of creation, and since Allah made humans human He created the means of their guidance. But all archaeological research to date has clearly shown that early man was not a monotheist but a polytheist. This is a contradiction for which I seek a solution.

In the form in which you have put the question, it is not acceptable. First, archaeology nowhere proves that the man of ancient times was a polytheist. This is a show staged by Western so-called sociologists or anthropologists; they fabricated this story and spread it in their educational institutions. I have discussed this in detail, with historical references and solid scientific references, in my book which is about to be published; I hope, by Allah's grace, it will be in your hands before our next Annual Convention. In it I have discussed it from every aspect. The most important point I can summarise here; it comes in detail in the book, here I put it briefly: this notion was constructed such that man, in his earliest stages, fell prostrate before whatever he found frightening. Right? This is categorically disproved by evolution as well, and categorically disproved by the early history of man known to us, because he was a hunter from the very beginning and became an agriculturist later. And it never happened that early man, on seeing a lion, prostrated before it, or out of fear of the elephant started worshipping it. That is an outright lie. Owing to his better brain he always fought all other creatures on earth with better weapons, and who fights against gods? This notion that out of fear he prostrated before lightning, prostrated before the storm, the notion of lions, ghosts and jinn, all of it is a lie. They based it on Greek mythology and Latin mythology, although even with reference to that mythology this can be shown to be entirely wrong. There too very great prophets appeared, and after the corruption of their teaching polytheism came, and this has been so since time immemorial. I have proven there that not even once did polytheism gradually develop into monotheism. Every time, monotheism split and broke apart and finally turned into polytheism. The Holy Qur’an has given such solid arguments for this that no sociologist in the world can answer them. After Hazrat Adam (as), by the time of Hazrat Noah (as), polytheism had set in. Adam was a monotheist and Noah was a monotheist, but the whole people had become polytheist. Noah strove for monotheism and God Almighty supported him. By the time Abraham came, polytheism had spread again. Monotheism deteriorates, it deteriorates, and the name of that deterioration is polytheism. Monotheism has never arisen from this deterioration. That would be a verdict against reason and history. After Hazrat Abraham (as), wherever you look at the chain of prophethood, polytheism arose after them in their own peoples; even in the lifetime of Moses it began. So polytheism is the name of the slope and monotheism the name of the height. Peoples naturally move from the difficult to the easy. So this is my challenge: show a single instance where polytheism gradually developed into monotheism. There are countless examples to the contrary. Look at the example of Guru Baba Nanak: he came from the Hindus, came out of the house of polytheism, stood firm on monotheism and strove against polytheism. So monotheism descends from heaven; it does not arise through evolution. This is a brief argument. I have there proven their theories completely wrong with reference to the Australian continent. When the book comes you will see that there is no room at all to deny that monotheism always deteriorates and turns into polytheism. If you do not want to go further back in history, look at the state of the Muslims: Islam sprang from the fountain of the monotheism of the Holy Prophet (saw), and what is happening in Pakistan today? Worship of the dead has become common, children are being asked of trees, some branch of some Pir supposedly cures the eyes, another cures gout. Everything is thoroughly corrupted. Every big official in Pakistan first presents himself at the court of Data, and then thinks that this will give him stability. Where polytheism is in this state ... In England the polytheist scholars are flourishing. Just look, they are making the poor people so ignorant, taking their money, exorcising jinn from them. They created the belief in jinn because they get their livelihood through the jinn, and who would kick his own livelihood? They kick a person in the stomach and kill him, but they cannot kick the jinn. This is the actual state of affairs, a historical fact which can be seen in the same way to this day. Jazakallah.

10 of 10 left today