8. The point is this: I am a Muslim, but not an Ahmadi. That does not mean I am against Ahmadis; everyone has their own belief. I have two questions. The first is very simple: what is basically the difference between the Ahmadi sect and the group that is not Ahmadi? If there is a difference, two communities have formed. The second question: we offer the prayer and you also offer it. Is there any difference between your prayer and ours? In other words, have you made any amendment or addition to the surahs we recite?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 February 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: The point is this: I am a Muslim, but not an Ahmadi. That does not mean I am against Ahmadis; everyone has their own belief. I have two questions. The first is very simple: what is basically the difference between the Ahmadi sect and the group that is not Ahmadi? If there is a difference, two communities have formed. The second question: we offer the prayer and you also offer it. Is there any difference between your prayer and ours? In other words, have you made any amendment or addition to the surahs we recite?
You called the first question simple, but it is so extensive that even hours would not settle it. For, out of naivety or from hearsay, you have formed the idea that on one side is the Ahmadi belief and on the other the belief of all other Muslims. That is not correct. Muslims are divided into seventy-two sects, and each sect differs from the others more than Ahmadis differ from Sunnis, Shias or others. I will tell you our basic, distinguishing belief, and explain that you should not fall into the misconception that all the rest hold one belief. There is a difference like that between heaven and earth among the beliefs of the other Muslims. For example, a friend from the Ismaili sect is sitting here. He can tell you that there is a difference like heaven and earth between the Ismaili belief and your Sunni belief; even the concept of Imamate is different. He can also tell you that there is a very great difference between the Twelver Shias and the Ismailis: in the manner of worship, in the construction of mosques, in which picture hangs in the mosque before which supplications are made. I mention them only as a distinct example because they are sitting here; ask them separately and they will tell you the same. So your question creates a wrong impression: the difference between Ahmadis and other Muslims is not that all others are united on the same beliefs and only Ahmadis believe differently. What then is the Ahmadi difference that separates everyone from the Ahmadis? It is only this: we believe that the Imam whom God was to send, whom He had promised, has already come and appeared; you sit waiting, you could not recognise him, or out of obstinacy and prejudice you have rejected him. The second basic difference is that Jesus (as) has died; he is not sitting alive in heaven. Do not ruin your future further by waiting for him. No one will descend from heaven; the one who was to come has come. He is the Jesus, in a metaphorical sense; he is the Mahdi. Accept him, it is for your good. The only solution to remove the division within Islam is to accept the one who has come from God, to come out of every sect and gather around him. We believe this is the one path to unity; once division has occurred, it can never be brought together except by an Imam sent from heaven. There is only one form of gathering: gather at the call of Allah. This is not an issue that cannot be understood. When Jesus (as) came, the community of Moses was divided into seventy-two sects. He did not present a formula by which the differences of the seventy-two sects were removed and all placed in one lap. The formula he presented was rejected by all; they denied his Imamate. And that was the first time that the community of Moses united on one thing in that era; it had never united before. The Holy Qur’an frequently mentions their differences and division: their hearts were torn apart, they were separated. On what did they unite? ‘Disbelief is one community’ – on the denial of the Imam of the age. Even torn-apart peoples unite on that. So today's question arises from this misunderstanding. The Ummah of Muhammad (saw) has been divided for a long time. Forget Ahmadiyyat: Wahhabis, Sunnis, Barelwis, Shias, Twelvers, Ismailis, then Alawites and so on. The differences have been so severe and frequent that there have been continual fights and bloodshed, mosques demolished, killing and slaughter, people burned alive over differences. The unity you see today is only a unity in rejecting Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as); there is no other attraction. Ask them: ‘Tell us one or two beliefs on which everyone is united’, and you will understand that they are not united at all. At the start every mosque held that Ramadan should begin on one day; when Eid came they split, they broke apart at once; they could not stay patient in unity for even one month. So this is the basic point: the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat was established to unite Muslims on this formula, which has always been Allah's formula: when people are torn apart and divided, Allah sends an Imam. That Imam is severely opposed, but the opposition cannot kill him. This is a definitive sign. False Imams also come, but they are wiped out in the opposition. He emerges from every opposition stronger than before; the more one tries to constrict him, the more he grows. See whether this history has manifested in favour of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat or not. And since these clerics opposed and united in opposition, what blessings has Allah granted these ‘holy warriors’ in Pakistan, where the opposition is greatest? Has the country not been torn to pieces? Has every group not separated from the other? Has respect for honour not vanished completely? Were there not gang rapes in Ramadan? Has the safety of children's lives not gone? Have kidnappings not increased? Robbery, theft, murder, explosions, looting at gunpoint – are these not daily occurrences in every home? Is this how God rewards His pious warrior servants? Since the clerics, especially of Pakistan, formed an alliance against Ahmadiyyat, study the history from that day until today and compare it with before: a difference like heaven and earth has occurred. Politics is torn apart, the provinces have separated, people's hearts are torn, oppression and cruelty prevail, justice has disappeared. Is this how God honours His pious, pure servants who strive for His sake? Have you ever heard of God bestowing such honour? If we are liars, these are confirmed liars, because God has shown them the treatment given to liars, which He has never given to the truthful. And what is our state? Since they tried to throw us out of Islam, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat has progressed so rapidly in the world that what did not happen in a hundred years before now happens in a single year. Last year, by the grace of Allah, the bai‘ats of one year that I accepted via television at the Jalsa Salana amounted to 1.6 million. Imagine: 1.6 million bai‘ats in one day – of a whole year, but gathered on one day. Before I came here, no Ahmadi could have dreamt of it; they used to be a few thousand. So God has begun a strange treatment. What has happened to God? So much blessing for the liars, and such hardship for the truthful that even the little truth that remained has been pulled out of them; so many lies are being told that one cannot count them. So reflect on these things and the reason for the difference will become clear to you: we were separated from the Ummah because of accepting an Imam, and they united on the basis of opposing that Imam, not because of agreement in belief among themselves. To this day, the Wahhabi belief remains Wahhabi and the Shia belief remains Shia. So what kind of agreement is this?