12. [Mr Sibghatullah Qadri, barrister and Queen's Counsel.] I came here to learn; asking a question was not my aim. But on the young man's question about the Ahmadi difference, you said very cogently that the other mullahs say a prophet will not come but an old prophet can come by the back door, and you say he can come by the front door. Conditions in the world are changing very fast, technology is changing, perhaps there may even be new life several times. In your view can another prophet come, is there a need for it? In my view, human opinion has no bearing on whether a prophet comes or not. The question should be: if Mirza Sahib is an Ummati prophet, as you say, is there any indication about him in the Holy Qur’an and Hadith? And if there is, is the possibility of another prophet also open?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 February 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [Mr Sibghatullah Qadri, barrister and Queen's Counsel.] I came here to learn; asking a question was not my aim. But on the young man's question about the Ahmadi difference, you said very cogently that the other mullahs say a prophet will not come but an old prophet can come by the back door, and you say he can come by the front door. Conditions in the world are changing very fast, technology is changing, perhaps there may even be new life several times. In your view can another prophet come, is there a need for it? In my view, human opinion has no bearing on whether a prophet comes or not. The question should be: if Mirza Sahib is an Ummati prophet, as you say, is there any indication about him in the Holy Qur’an and Hadith? And if there is, is the possibility of another prophet also open?
This question is valid. We always speak with reference to the Holy Qur’an and Hadith. The Holy Qur’an has not closed the door of Ummati prophethood, nor has it said that only one will come. Understood? Therefore no one has the right to say that the door is open but only for one. If an Ahmadi says so, he is wrong. The door is open, with conditions; the one in whose favour those conditions are fulfilled will certainly be a prophet of Allah. And these conditions the Holy Prophet (saw) confirmed, or himself stated, in the prophecies about the Imam Mahdi and Messiah to come in the Ummah of Muhammad. We only say that it was Mirza Sahib's duty to point out those prophecies that were fulfilled in his favour; without that he would have no right to any claim. He may have received revelation, but how would the world know whether he did or not? But if the verses of the Holy Qur’an and the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (saw) bear witness in his favour as clear as daylight, then everyone will know. Regarding the future, our position is: if God sends someone – since the door is not closed, an Ummati prophet can come – then it will be his task; no one will accept him until he proves the truth of his being with reference to the Holy Qur’an and Hadith. That is his task. First of all he has not yet appeared; how should we worry about the next one? But my basic answer to you is: the door that is open is open conditionally. That verse is a verse of Surah An-Nisa, completely definitive and clear: ‘And whoso obeys Allah and the Messenger shall be among those on whom Allah has bestowed His blessings – the Prophets, the Truthful, the Martyrs and the Righteous; and excellent companions are these.’ Whoever obeys Allah and His Messenger Muhammad (saw) shall be among those whom Allah has blessed. The group known as the blessed group – only these people will be included in it. Who are those whom Allah has blessed? He said: from among the Prophets, and from the Truthful, and from the Martyrs, and from the Righteous. See what a good companionship it is – what a wonderful company. This verse is so clear and open that it does not close the path to the blessed group but opens it with this condition: obedience to Allah and Muhammad the Chosen One (saw) is essential. The degree of obedience will decide in which group you are worthy of being counted; Allah will make this decision. But the condition of ‘only one’ is nowhere. Therefore this is the path with these conditions; as long as these conditions continue to be fulfilled, Allah the Exalted will respond fully as He has promised. Alright?