15. [From the ladies:] If Allah the Exalted can create Jesus (as) without a father, then He can also raise him to heaven.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 February 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: [From the ladies:] If Allah the Exalted can create Jesus (as) without a father, then He can also raise him to heaven.

Quite right, He can raise him. But it is not that He raises him and tells no one. That is exactly what we ask: if He raised him, why did He not say so? If He can create without a father, then He can raise not only Jesus but others too. Is there a condition that He raises only the one He creates without a father? He can raise others too. And Elijah was not born without a father, yet his being raised to heaven is mentioned. That is why the mullahs stick this argument onto everything: anyone may claim he has gone to heaven – and what is the argument? He can create without a father, can He not raise to heaven? That is no argument. An argument is formed only thus: the stranger the event, the stronger the testimony required. This is essential, a general rule in human life. If I give someone an ordinary piece of news, he will accept it; it makes no difference to him. But if I say, I was walking and a pole turned into a horse, he will not accept it and will say: what nonsense is he talking, give proof! If I say: if He can create without a father, can He not turn a pole into a horse? – what will the mullahs answer? If he is not a mullah: He can. But the stranger the event, the greater the proof. The Holy Qur’an has not presented this proof, has not mentioned, that Allah the Exalted raised Jesus (as) alive to heaven and that he is still sitting alive in heaven. If it had said so, why would it then announce his death elsewhere? And announce it so clearly that anyone with even ordinary sense cannot shut his eyes to it – except through prejudice; when the blindfold of prejudice is on, one can deny anything. I will present to you only two verses on this subject so that the matter is settled. The first verse: about Jesus (as) Allah the Exalted says: ‘The Messiah, son of Mary, was only a Messenger; surely Messengers have passed away before him; and his mother was a truthful woman; they both used to eat food.’ The Messiah, son of Mary, was nothing but a Messenger, and before him all Messengers have passed away, not one remains. When you hear this announcement, what do you take it as proof of? Because he was a Messenger and all Messengers before him have passed away, therefore he will not pass away? If someone draws that conclusion, it would be foolishness. This idiom exists in every language: he is only human, and every human makes mistakes. If this is said, the conclusion will be that he too has made a mistake. So this is a general rule that was stated: see, do not give the Messiah a rank higher than a Messenger; he was only a Messenger, and before him all Messengers have passed away. Only one conclusion follows: that Jesus (as) has died. But to break the doubt of those who doubt, the Holy Qur’an takes the subject further in the same verse and says: ‘and his mother was a truthful woman’ – his mother was a chaste, truthful woman. ‘They both used to eat food’ – mother and son used to eat food at some past time. Now every sensible person will immediately understand what wisdom lies in this: by mentioning the mother, the mention of the son apparently ended. When her death was mentioned, it was mentioned in this way: she has died, she has given up eating, and along with her the Messiah too has given up eating; both used to eat food at some time, now they do not. So the meaning of ‘khalat’ (passed away) has been fully opened and made clear. If someone tells you: it says ‘before Jesus’, Jesus is not included, we do not accept – then I would say to him: Sir, when the Holy Qur’an decides a matter, no power in the world can defeat it; whatever it wishes to prove, it will prove. For there is another verse of exactly the same form about the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw). He said: ‘And Muhammad is only a Messenger; surely Messengers have passed away before him.’ Muhammad, however exalted his rank, is still only a Messenger, and before him all Messengers have passed away. Now tell me: will they accept that Jesus was earlier or not? Was Jesus earlier or not? Was he a Messenger or not? If he was, where will they take this verse which says: ‘And Muhammad is only a Messenger; surely Messengers have passed away before him’? Secondly, why was Jesus spoken of specifically? It proves that false beliefs were to arise about this prophet; he was to be regarded as alive in heaven. To refute this, Allah the Exalted placed these verses as a pair, between which Jesus (as) is so caught that he cannot escape alive. So he died like the ordinary prophets. That he did not die on the cross is beyond any doubt. He survived, migrated, and like the other prophets completed his mission. Two tribes of Israel were at that time in Judea and Palestine; had he, after conveying the message to them, ascended to heaven, his prophethood would not have been fulfilled, for there were twelve tribes to whom he was sent. That is why Jesus (as) himself prophesied that he would leave you and go to the lost sheep of the house of Israel – ‘the sheep of the house of Israel, the lost sheep of the house of Israel’ are the words. Where the lost sheep had gone, there he had to go; sheep do not ascend to heaven. Therefore the Holy Qur’an has settled the matter of the death of Jesus (as). So when a person has died and his coming is spoken of, it is always fulfilled metaphorically; it is a likeness. This very subject was raised in the time of Jesus (as) himself, and Jesus (as) gave the verdict. About the prophet Elijah – as I just told you – this very belief is recorded in the Bible, that he ascended to heaven sitting in a chariot of fire and would descend before the coming of the Messiah sitting in the same chariot. When the Messiah came and no Elijah descended – just as today Muslims ask the Ahmadis: ‘first bring the Messiah down, then we will accept Mirza Sahib's claim’ – in the same way the Jewish clerics mocked Jesus and said to him: where have you come from first? Bring Elijah and show us. Jesus' answer is the answer of truth, which resolves this issue forever. He pointed to John the Baptist – keep his mention in mind – and said: this John the Baptist is that Elijah who was to descend from heaven; if you wish, accept it, if you wish, do not; your matter is with God. So when people descend from heaven, how do they descend? They are born on earth, after the pattern of earlier saints, after their character, or they come with similar issues, with the solution of similar problems. If these resemblances are proven, the new one is given the name of the old, as John was given the name of Elijah. So this is our belief: that according to the Holy Qur’an Jesus (as) is definitively proven to have died; therefore whoever is to come must come as a likeness. The debate is not whether it is possible for Allah. When did I say it is impossible? Nothing is impossible for Allah the Exalted. But it is impossible that He departs from His law and decree and does not even mention it – that cannot be – or even proves the opposite: on one side says, I raised Jesus alive to heaven, and on the other says, he has died like the other prophets. How can there be a contradiction in the Word of God? That is more impossible than what they call ‘impossible’.

10 of 10 left today