4. Basir Afridi from Wimbledon, a microbiologist in research: I have brought two questions, one on science and one on the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Cloning is much talked about nowadays. What is the reality of it, and what is the Islamic viewpoint?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Basir Afridi from Wimbledon, a microbiologist in research: I have brought two questions, one on science and one on the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Cloning is much talked about nowadays. What is the reality of it, and what is the Islamic viewpoint?
Regarding cloning, first a misunderstanding must be removed: the Western press presents cloning as though man has become capable of creation. This is completely wrong; there is not the slightest truth in it. To this day man has not been able to make even a single component of DNA. Human 'creation' means stealing God's creation: taking it from one place and fitting it in another, while the capacity to fit was already present in that creation. This aspect also relates to cloning. And the idea that cells are put into a machine and ready-formed humans keep coming out is entirely false and wrong. A human mother is needed, and without a human mother … this cloning too is not possible. And with animals, if you want to produce a sheep, a sheep will be needed; there is no such minting factory as people imagine. As far as its nature is concerned, man has not been able to create anything; he has begun interfering in creation after reading its secrets.
The Holy Qur’an gave a clear warning about this. All the prophecies in the Holy Qur’an have a tone of praise: see, man will invent this, and that too, in accordance with Allah's guidance. For instance, where the earth's bringing forth its heavy metals, casting out its secrets is mentioned, He says: 'bi-anna Rabbaka awha laha' – the earth will bring out those secrets because God will reveal to it: now the time has come, do not keep these treasures hidden, bring them out so that man can benefit. But where interference in creation is prophesied, it is attributed to Satan. It says: Satan will cast whisperings into the hearts of My servants and tell them, alter the creation. And after that comes an expression of displeasure: when they do it, they will be punished for it. So whether cloning or genetic engineering, both are already mentioned with great clarity in the Holy Qur’an, with the warning: do not think you will escape punishment.
So there are two aspects. One is that man uses his knowledge in accordance with God's creation for its protection and preservation; this aspect is not at all impermissible. For example the test-tube baby: if it is the father's sperm and the mother's ovum, then helping them produce a child is the purpose of marriage; it is among the purposes of human creation. Therefore trying to derive from the Holy Qur’an that this is forbidden is false and absurd. … (gap in the recording) … is Allah's creation, and the reality will remain that the son, who ought to have come from that mother, is not from that mother; he has become as it were the mother's stepson. As for saying that the ovum was taken from the mother: scientists who truly know the secret of human birth know that the mere presence of the ovum is not enough. For nine months the child takes blood from the mother, takes various characteristics from her, and acquires many capacities that do not come from the original ovum. So it is wrong to say that it is purely the child of the first mother. It will certainly become something of a wonder: part it took from the mother, and the rest from a woman who has no right to be a mother, since she is not joined by the bond of marriage. Whether you do it through cloning or by some other means, the Holy Qur’an has stated its principles and also warned very clearly.
And we are seeing the results: in the experiments in America on altering creation, against which God has given a very strong warning, some new animals have come into being which, by scientific reckoning, should not have been produced. For example, a gene was taken from a bacterium, and the chromosomes of a mouse were taken, its genes and the … chromosomes into which genes fit, and it was fitted there. Scientists overlooked that every gene has a relationship with another gene – its position, and in the circle in which the chromosomes revolve, which gene faces which; from this its attributes arise within the cell, and if this arrangement is changed the thing becomes something else. (A listener suggests it was a mouse.) No, in these early experiments it was not a sheep; it concerned insects. To help agriculture they were trying to create insects resistant to common diseases but which would eat certain disease-causing pests. That is what I am talking about. But the insect, whatever came into being, astonished them; its character was not what they had thought it should be. In this respect several cases are currently pending in the major courts of the United States; many scientists have become worried, and the danger is that man, though he cannot create his own creation, may become the slave of a corrupted creation, and that it may take hold of his environment such that something above man, or some genetic kind of creature that overpowers man, arises. This is basically the teaching of the Holy Qur’an; it relates both to cloning and to genetic engineering.