6. Muhammad Salim Askar from North London: I feel as if in this whole gathering I am utterly ignorant of religion, since my question is worded somewhat like this … (humorous anecdote about a naive question in Punjab). My question: did Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) claim prophethood or to be the Promised Messiah? And if he claimed prophethood, what is meant by Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (the Seal of Prophethood)?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Muhammad Salim Askar from North London: I feel as if in this whole gathering I am utterly ignorant of religion, since my question is worded somewhat like this … (humorous anecdote about a naive question in Punjab). My question: did Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) claim prophethood or to be the Promised Messiah? And if he claimed prophethood, what is meant by Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (the Seal of Prophethood)?

Do not worry – as Ghalib's verse says: practise your coquetry, the guilt of my blood is on my neck. A very good question. Listen carefully: when I state Hazrat Mirza Sahib's (as) claim, you will not find a particle of difference between our belief and that of the non-Ahmadi scholars as far as the status of the one to come is concerned. The difference is only about the person. The Holy Prophet (saw), on whom the verses of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat were revealed, necessarily understood those verses better than any other human; it cannot even be imagined that a mullah knows the meaning of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat better than the Holy Prophet (saw). And the prophecy of the Mahdi and the Messiah was made by the Holy Prophet (saw). Muhammad (saw) himself called the Messiah 'Nabiyyullah' (Prophet of Allah). And the definition he gave of the Mahdi is, in the Holy Qur’an, the definition of the Prophets. After enumerating the lists of Prophets, the Holy Qur’an says: these are those whom We made Imams – 'wa ja‘alnahum a'immatan yahduna bi-amrina' – such Imams who were not guided by themselves but received Our guidance and passed it on. In 'al-Imam al-Mahdi' both components are included, i.e. it is the Prophets who are Imam Mahdi; no non-Prophet can be Imam Mahdi, because Allah stated the condition: We make him Imam and We give him guidance; if he is worthy of guidance then he is the Imam Mahdi – and this is exactly what Allah also called prophethood. These are the two components about whose real meaning the scholars do not differ with us. For example, ask them: the Imam Mahdi who was to come has not yet come – why don't you make one yourselves? Make someone Imam and follow him, and the Imam Mahdi will have come. They will look at you as at an utterly ignorant person: surely God has to appoint the Imam Mahdi, and he is Mahdi because he receives guidance from Allah. Then what else is the definition of a Prophet? A Prophet is a rank whose denial Allah does not permit; and about the Imam Mahdi all scholars agree that whoever denies him becomes a disbeliever – not a single exception. To give it another name with the mouth and use the definition of prophethood – what would one call that? I call it naivety; I cannot say more than that.

Regarding the Messiah they find another loophole. They say: about the Messiah we must necessarily accept that he is a Prophet of Allah; indeed all the great muftis have issued the edict that whoever does not accept the coming Messiah as a Prophet is outside Islam and has no connection with Islam. When we ask: then what does Khatm-e-Nubuwwat mean – on one side the verse 'Khatam-un-Nabiyyin', and on the other the descent in the Ummah, after the demise of Muhammad (saw), of a person who will be called Prophet and perform the duties of a Prophet? – they say: people don't understand this; Khatm-e-Nubuwwat means that the making of Prophets has now stopped, but the use of an old Prophet is permissible. This logic may satisfy a mullah, but it cannot satisfy a person of ordinary common sense. For the question arises: if a Prophet was needed, why was it stopped? And meeting the need by bringing an old Prophet through the back door is against the dignity of Allah. So the debate is only about the need: will it be met by bringing the old one, or will one be raised within the Ummah of Muhammad? These are side matters. They accept the need, i.e. after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw), who is Khatam-un-Nabiyyin, the need for prophethood did not end – and prophethood has ended, that is their belief. And in the next breath they say how God will meet the need: see, He raised Jesus (as) and seated him in the fourth heaven, and two thousand years have passed – for the sake of that very need. We say: if within the Ummah of Muhammad a servant of the Holy Prophet (saw) is made a Prophet, who is his follower and brings (no) new prophethood and (no) new law – does that seem better to you, or a Prophet borrowed from the Ummah of Moses? They say: be that as it may, the making of prophethood has stopped, so we will take an old Prophet.

This logic of theirs is so absurd – forgive me, the word is harsh, but when I explain it to you, there will be no other choice. The reason is that about that very Messiah whom they say is sitting alive in heaven and will return, the unalterable Holy Qur’an says: 'wa rasulan ila Bani Isra'il' – Jesus is a Messenger to the Children of Israel. Now if the Messiah descends, he will have to abrogate this verse; if he abrogates it, all the scholars will be after his life: who are you to abrogate the Holy Qur’an? If he says, I have been sent as a Messenger to the Ummah of Muhammad, anyone can rise and object: look, the Holy Qur’an says you are a Messenger of the Children of Israel; what right do you have to exercise messengership in the Ummah of Muhammad? Then to call him the former Messenger is quite childish, because he was a Messenger for a limited people and a limited time. Whoever is to exercise messengership in the Ummah of Muhammad must necessarily have a universal messengership. And when the Messenger of the Children of Israel was made a universal Messenger, another Messenger came into being; his entire definition changed. These are the reasons why I insist that, in terms of belief, despite the revelation of the verse Khatam-un-Nabiyyin, the non-Ahmadi scholars and we alike believe in the need for prophethood; both also agree on the limitation of the need for prophethood, and both agree regarding Messiahship. The only question is whether that old Messenger who was raised to heaven two thousand years ago will descend, or whether God will raise a spiritual son from the Ummah of Muhammad. Understood? Thank you.

10 of 10 left today