7. My question concerns the relationship between religion and humanity. First of all, what is the relationship between religion and humanity? Secondly, what is its significance in the Hereafter? We believe in the Hereafter, that in the Hereafter Allah the Exalted will judge the deeds of human beings. A person who is a Christian, a Sikh or a Jew, but who in practice does what our religion teaches, takes care of his neighbour and does what Allah the Exalted has said, only he does not recite the Kalima – how will Allah the Exalted treat such people? Please explain.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My question concerns the relationship between religion and humanity. First of all, what is the relationship between religion and humanity? Secondly, what is its significance in the Hereafter? We believe in the Hereafter, that in the Hereafter Allah the Exalted will judge the deeds of human beings. A person who is a Christian, a Sikh or a Jew, but who in practice does what our religion teaches, takes care of his neighbour and does what Allah the Exalted has said, only he does not recite the Kalima – how will Allah the Exalted treat such people? Please explain.
The first question: what is the relationship between religion and humanity? I mentioned evolution a moment ago. Evolution took billions of years to reach the stage of man; since man was created it is, by comparison, a matter of a few days. There is no comparison between the human era and the era before it. But a difference arose which distinguished man from all forms of life and raised him above them. None of the species of life was granted the discernment to decide between good and bad deeds, nor were they given free will. Therefore the code, that is the law (Shariah) and teaching, relates to good and bad. Upon things which had no awareness of what is good and what is bad, no Shariah could be revealed. With this awareness, and with freedom within this awareness: both paths have been opened before you – ‘Whoever wishes, let him believe, and whoever wishes, let him disbelieve’; ‘There is no compulsion in religion.’ God will use no compulsion in religion; whoever wishes may accept, whoever wishes may reject, and God will judge it. So religion is related to free will, and this free will was granted, in the universe and in the evolution of life, first of all to man. Not even the angels received it, nor any other creature except man. This free will necessarily requires teaching. If I am free to do good or bad, then neither I nor anyone else can possibly have the power to decide on every occasion what is good and bad. For this Allah the Exalted established two systems, both of which the Holy Qur’an mentions. One system is that He placed within man a basic capacity to distinguish the genuine from the counterfeit. If he closes his eyes, that is his choice; but anywhere in the world, of whatever civilisation or age a person may be, his heart bears witness, when he wrongs or torments someone, whether these are good things; and a vague notion of rights exists in every person. This is a universal testimony that Allah the Exalted, when He created man and gave him free will, did not make it necessary that a religion must first be revealed for him to know things clearly; He created a religion within his consciousness. This is the teaching about which Allah the Exalted says in the Holy Qur’an: ‘The nature made by Allah, according to which He has created mankind.’ Allah has created human beings upon His own nature. And what is the nature of God? The attributes of the Exalted: Rububiyyat (providence), Rahmaniyyat (grace), not committing injustice, showing mercy, strengthening bonds of love, consideration for one another. God bends down from His loftiness and values man. All these matters this single verse has opened up to us: that there is a Shariah which is embedded in our being, our particles, our cells. And yet, because man does not listen to this voice and, misusing his free will, inclines more towards selfishness, the need arose for the revelation of a Shariah for him. The teaching that comes from heaven is revealed to one man; he tells that God the Exalted has prescribed this code of life for you. And the greatest proof of its truth is that this code of life accords with the code of his nature. That is why people needlessly get entangled in arguments about what the sign of a prophet’s truth is and of his falsehood. So clear a sign is written there that even a person of the slightest reflection will recognise the truth from the teaching. If someone has come with a pure teaching, there is no reason at all to reject him. What is the harm in calling him a prophet? He is leading towards goodness, isn’t he? And if Allah did not make him a prophet, has he then gone mad that he is leading towards God? And if Satan made him, then why has he gone mad that instead of a satanic teaching he gives a good, well-ordered teaching in accordance with human nature and builds a good, well-ordered community? So the greatest proof, which can satisfy a person to the depth of his heart, the sign of the truth of a prophet or a servant of God, is that his teaching is in accordance with the teaching of nature, that his moral teaching is in accordance with the demands of the highest human morals, and that he builds a community. This, then, is the relationship of Shariah to religion and of religion to humanity. I cannot go into further detail, but, Masha’Allah, from your face it seems you are understanding the matter. The second aspect remains, the Hereafter. As far as the Hereafter is concerned: although it is possible that a person sometimes, owing to the good influence of his society, if he is fortunate enough to have it, or owing to the natural states of his cells, inclines towards good instead of evil – one child is of blessed nature, good-hearted, has love in him, listens to words of love and understands; another child inclines towards mischief, the poor thing is brought up in the environment of filthy streets, harshness, plunder, lies and filth are already part of his temperament; another child is a descendant of prophets and is raised in a very pure and holy environment – in all these things there is a profound message of wisdom: if every person simply dies according to his evil or his goodness, then this universe has no purpose at all. A wicked person dying while committing mischief attains salvation and faces no danger of punishment. The only remedy for this thought of every oppressor and criminal – that if I do not come to the notice of the law in my lifetime, I can commit as much injustice as I like and get away with it – is the concept of the Day of the Hereafter and belief in it. Good people are of several kinds. Some regard goodness itself as their reward; these are people of the highest rank. But there are many whose goodness stems from the temperament they have inherited, and that goodness does not deserve reward. For example, a eunuch, whom God has not given the capacity for sexual relations, says: ‘O Allah, reward me, I am a very pious man, I have never looked at any woman with an evil eye.’ If the logic you are presenting were accepted one hundred per cent, he ought to be rewarded. But reward is given to the one in whom the opposite inclination exists and who then refrains in the thought that Allah the Exalted forbids it. When one refrains on being told, there is reward for it. If one refrains without being told, owing to the demands of circumstances, that is a good thing, but not deserving of reward. So this is the philosophy of the relationship of reward and punishment on the Last Day, which I have briefly placed before you.