8. I wanted to ask: is it then true that only those who recite the Kalima will go to Paradise?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: I wanted to ask: is it then true that only those who recite the Kalima will go to Paradise?
I am just about to explain that; this is a third aspect of your question. In this regard Allah the Exalted has laid down a very simple and extremely reliable principle, after which all these matters are settled for us. Allah the Exalted says: ‘Allah does not burden any soul beyond its capacity. It shall have what it has earned, and against it what it has wrought.’ Allah the Exalted has made it binding on Himself that He will not bind any soul to anything beyond the capacity He has granted it. For the good it has earned He will certainly reward; for the evil it has earned it may be punished – whether He forgives is a separate matter. Now these are things which man cannot determine from what is called his vantage point, the position from which he views things, because there are countless deceptions in human nature. One human being cannot even fully understand another, with what motive someone did what. So if the rejection of Islam is due to a disease of the heart, it is punishable, and deeds cannot then intercede for him in his way, in his assessment. Because fundamentally, rejecting the Messenger of Allah means rejecting the supremacy of Allah the Exalted. And this is the significance, the most important thing, the philosophy of accepting prophethood. Allah the Exalted has described this significance through the story of the beginning of creation. About Satan He said that when Allah made Adam, perfected him and breathed His spirit into him, that is, blessed him with revelation, He told the angels to prostrate before him. Then Satan said: he is inferior to me; I was created from fire and You created him from clay; therefore it is beneath my dignity to prostrate before someone inferior to me. Allah the Exalted, instead of giving an argument, said: begone, you rejected one. And people wonder why He gave no argument. The argument has already been given in this style of narration. Because no one besides the Creator has the right to be prostrated to – neither man, nor tree, nor stone, nor anything – except one whom the Creator makes His representative. In ‘We breathed into him of Our spirit’ this subject is set out: when We breathed Our spirit, that is, adorned him with Our revelation and made him Our appointed representative, then the debate cannot arise whether in himself he is superior or inferior. Because in themselves there were superior and inferior things before too, and no other creature had been commanded to be prostrated to. Therefore bowing the head before one appointed by God is subordinate to the basic principle that bowing the head before Allah is our duty. We are not permitted to enter into the debate whether we see him as better or lesser than ourselves. If it is proven that Allah appointed him, then further debates are over. So if a person, born into whatever religion, has received the message of Islam in such a way that he is capable of understanding it, but his misdeeds, worldliness, materialism and the demands of his environment stand in his way, then his decency will be of no avail to him. There are many such people in Europe with whom I have spoken. They say: yes, we accept, we have acknowledged that your argument is correct, but we do not have the ability; to leave our society, to separate from our background, we do not have the strength for that. Such a person, knowing that the Holy Prophet (saw) was appointed as a representative by Allah and that he alone is the Messenger for the whole world, has rejected him by putting forward his compulsions. So rejection also happens because of such compulsions; it can also happen out of mischief. The Holy Qur’an shows that the punishment for mischief is greater and for this kind of people comparatively less, but punishment for this rejection will certainly be given. And if you understand the concept of punishment, this philosophy becomes even more acceptable to human nature. The meaning of punishment in relation to religion is that a person remains deprived of the possibilities of progress connected with something; that is his punishment. If a rich man’s child has all the opportunities of education and the means as well, but falls in with his peers and in their friendship becomes used to wasting time, and he rejects his parents, then outwardly he has not been punished, not handed over to the law. But what greater punishment can there be than that his brothers keep progressing and reach high positions, become senior officers, become very wealthy, are the best in worldly terms, become scientists, while he wanders the streets eating dust? So God the Exalted has decreed some punishments together with the offence itself. What greater punishment can there be than that the best Prophet comes, brings the perfect teaching which is necessary to bring the soul to life, and yet he is raised blind? When he refuses to see, his eyes become blind. That is why the Holy Qur’an said that when some people are raised blind they will say: O God, why have You raised us blind when in life I was seeing? Allah the Exalted will say: no, in life, despite the power to see, you remained deprived of seeing. These are some subtle points, but if I went into further detail it would take a very long time.