14. Hudhur, this question is from Mr. Abdur Rashid Pal, who has come from North London and is present here in the hall. He asked that I read the question. Regarding sacrifice (Qurbani) in the light of Islamic philosophy: is it not necessary that a person of means performs the sacrifice himself, rather than telling someone: I will send the money, or I am sending it, you perform the sacrifice? To what extent is this correct?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Hudhur, this question is from Mr. Abdur Rashid Pal, who has come from North London and is present here in the hall. He asked that I read the question. Regarding sacrifice (Qurbani) in the light of Islamic philosophy: is it not necessary that a person of means performs the sacrifice himself, rather than telling someone: I will send the money, or I am sending it, you perform the sacrifice? To what extent is this correct?
As far as sacrifice is concerned: the sacrifice which is obligatory is only for the pilgrims, on the occasion of Hajj; in the sacred precinct (Haram) sacrifice is obligatory. For the rest, the Holy Qur’an nowhere mentions any obligation of sacrifice. Therefore they perform it in support of the Hajj sacrifice in order to earn reward. And when it is for the sake of reward, one should keep the meaning of reward in view. To wield the knife with one's own hand, in a society where people are already going mad from eating meat, where mad cow disease has become common, while elsewhere the poor Muslim is dying of hunger or the African is dying of hunger, and not to have the sacrifice performed there so that one gets the reward oneself, will one get reward or punishment? If someone, out of fondness, also makes a small sacrifice here for the sake of blessing, I do not speak against it. But in such countries it is better for a Muslim to have sacrifices performed in his poor countries, for the sake of his brothers who do not get meat even once a year except what they receive on the day of sacrifice. For Allah the Exalted says, it is a verse of the Holy Qur’an, that neither the flesh of the sacrifices reaches Allah nor the blood, but the righteousness (Taqwa) of your hearts reaches Him. So if you have the sacrifice performed in another country with righteousness, the righteousness will reach God. The reward is for righteousness, not for the meat. All right.