16. Hudhur, this question is from Mr. Abdullah Yasmin Khan, who lives in Mildur(?). He could not come, he is not well today, so he has sent the question in writing. That section of Muslims belonging to the fundamentalist Muslims is in favour of resuming Jihad according to the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah with the same importance as in the early period of Islam. Now circumstances are different. What is Hudhur's view on this?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Hudhur, this question is from Mr. Abdullah Yasmin Khan, who lives in Mildur(?). He could not come, he is not well today, so he has sent the question in writing. That section of Muslims belonging to the fundamentalist Muslims is in favour of resuming Jihad according to the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah with the same importance as in the early period of Islam. Now circumstances are different. What is Hudhur's view on this?
First of all, there have already been quite serious debates. Let me tell you a joke about fundamentalists. A gentleman was giving a speech that 'fundamentalist' is actually a Punjabi word. They understand 'fund' – this fund, that fund – it is a Punjabi word. So fundamentalists are those who collect funds in the name of Allah and live off them. That was the incident; that is how they understand the word. But 'fundamentalist' is a term that has not even a remote connection with reality. The fundamentals are the Holy Qur’an and what are established as the roots of the Shariah; those are the fundamentals, the principles of law. Among them are the Holy Qur’an, the Sunnah, the Hadith, and if something cannot be found in them, then consensus (Ijma). These are the fundamentals. Those who are called fundamentalists today are people who follow the scholars of the East of the Middle Ages. They go neither to the Holy Qur’an nor to the Sunnah. However much you try to pull them out of the middle period and take them to the Holy Prophet (saw), they will not go. I will give you an example right now that you can test. Ask them: tell me, if someone calls himself a Muslim and you disagree with the details of his beliefs, do you have the right to call him a non-Muslim, even though he calls himself a Muslim? (They say:) For Islam is not merely professing and saying, there are other things too; if we do not see the Islamic things in them, we have the right to declare him non-Muslim. The first question should be: you are fundamentalists; was there anyone more fundamentalist than the Holy Prophet (saw)? Show one single example from his whole life where the Holy Prophet (saw) declared someone a non-Muslim who called himself a Muslim. A single incident. So how are these fundamentalists? They have become deniers of the fundamentals. They use the beliefs of their religion for themselves in order to commit injustice, to bend the necks of mankind, and call it fundamental. For the conduct of the Holy Prophet (saw) there was a basis in the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an itself said that these hypocrites testify under oath that you are the Messenger of Allah, and Allah testifies that you are indeed the Messenger of Allah, but Allah testifies that they are lying. Then He said: 'Faith has not yet entered their hearts' – faith has not even peeped into their hearts. And then He said that they are making a pretext; they have made the claim of faith a shield for themselves; they have no connection with faith or with Islam. Even so He said: tell them, do not call yourselves believers (Mu'min), but your right to be called Muslims remains established; if you wish to call yourselves Muslims, keep doing so. 'Say: we have accepted Islam.' God is saying they are not (true) Muslims, yet He says: as far as the basic human right is concerned, O Muhammad, give them this right; if they say we are Muslims, accept them as Muslims. The Holy Prophet (saw) exercised this right with such grandeur, without exception, in favour of all mankind, that through it, as it were, new shining stars appeared in the sky of religion. I give an example of an occasion where it was not even a question of exercising one's own right, against God's will: a Muslim, after great effort, threw down a warring opponent. There was fighting, Jihad was taking place. When he was about to draw the knife, that is the sword, across his neck, the man said: I bear witness that Allah is One. Now it was obvious that he was saying it to save his life. Again he said: Allah is One. Now he is saying it to save his life – and he drew the knife anyway. When he related the incident to the Holy Prophet (saw), to gain praise for himself, to get approval, the narrator himself relates: I never saw the Holy Prophet (saw) so angry in his whole life. He kept saying: 'Did you cut open his heart? Did you cut open his heart?' You wrongdoer, you should have torn open his chest and looked whether he was lying. The meaning was that besides God no one can be aware of the secret of the human heart. Then he said: what will your answer be on the Day of Judgement, when his heart (his testimony) will stand before you as a witness? This is our lord and master, Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw). And these Maulvis, the declarers of disbelief, keep making sect after sect disbelievers and expelling them, and those keep saying: I am (a Muslim), and these say: no, not at all, we know there is no Islam in your heart. To call them fundamentalists is a great injustice. Therefore the term is being misused. What more can you say about it.