17. Hudhur, this is the last question, from Mr. Javed Iqbal, who has come from Southall. Assalamu alaikum. Please go ahead. My first request is, I will try to have you speak Punjabi; I like your Punjabi very much. (Hudhur: I see, you like this put-on Punjabi.) My question is: with as much knowledge and awareness as I have about Islam – we are certainly Muslims, have read your great books, how you present arguments to people. I had heard some things, that some things are proven and some are not, but inside there was no firmness. I wanted to ask: Hazrat Abu Talib, Hazrat Maula ... What do you think: did he recite the declaration of faith (Kalima)? Did he accept Islam? Is that known? Is it also known that he performed the marriage of the Holy Prophet (saw), solemnised the Nikah – it is in books – that he read the Nikah of the Prophet?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 April 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: Hudhur, this is the last question, from Mr. Javed Iqbal, who has come from Southall. Assalamu alaikum. Please go ahead. My first request is, I will try to have you speak Punjabi; I like your Punjabi very much. (Hudhur: I see, you like this put-on Punjabi.) My question is: with as much knowledge and awareness as I have about Islam – we are certainly Muslims, have read your great books, how you present arguments to people. I had heard some things, that some things are proven and some are not, but inside there was no firmness. I wanted to ask: Hazrat Abu Talib, Hazrat Maula ... What do you think: did he recite the declaration of faith (Kalima)? Did he accept Islam? Is that known? Is it also known that he performed the marriage of the Holy Prophet (saw), solemnised the Nikah – it is in books – that he read the Nikah of the Prophet?
The Nikah of the Holy Prophet (saw) – at that time there was no prophethood yet, when the first marriage of the Holy Prophet (saw) took place with Hazrat Khadijah. The marriage of the Holy Prophet (saw) took place long before the claim of prophethood, fifteen years earlier: at twenty-five years; at forty he was granted prophethood. Fifteen years earlier he read the Nikah; the Nikah he read fifteen years earlier – do you understand? This is a story the Maulvis have invented so that his reciting of the Kalima would be proven, that he recited the Kalima. Regarding Hazrat Abu Talib, there is no conclusive proof anywhere of his reciting the Kalima. But there is also no proof of his being an idolater. Therefore we can by no means count Hazrat Abu Talib among the group about whom the Holy Qur’an has given the verdict that they are idolaters, that one should not even pray for them and that they will not enter Paradise. So his case lies in between. He gave full protection to his nephew, the young nephew whom he was raising, and made sacrifices. But among the Arabs there was a particular temperament; perhaps that temperament stood in the way, or he did not want to separate from his people. He did not recite the Kalima, but to say that in his heart he did not believe in the Prophet's truthfulness, I cannot accept. The reason is that Hazrat Abu Talib was a very enlightened, clear-minded person. A child growing up in his own house, truthful from childhood, how could he consider him a liar? Impossible. Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq comes from outside and believes without asking for proof, because this is the face of a truthful one. How then could Abu Talib say that he is a liar? Therefore I also stated this in the Dars and presented this quotation of the Promised Messiah (as) as well, that although no conclusive proof of his reciting the Kalima is before us, it is – God forbid – a sin to regard him as an idolater and a dweller of Hell. No one has any right to do so. There is not a single testimony that he ever prostrated before an idol. Understood? Done.