2. Sir, I would like to make a small submission – no offence, since we are talking one should speak, so the heart is reassured. When a Mubahala takes place and prayers are made, the punishment should not fall on these poor people, but on those who tell lies and lead people astray.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 May 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Sir, I would like to make a small submission – no offence, since we are talking one should speak, so the heart is reassured. When a Mubahala takes place and prayers are made, the punishment should not fall on these poor people, but on those who tell lies and lead people astray.

I am coming to that now; the answer to that is separate, I will give it later. The invitation to the Mubahala was to the entire nation. But perhaps you forget that when the Ulema mislead, it is the common people who commit the injustice. Following them, it is the common people who burn houses – illiterate people, poor people. And the same is happening in politics, everywhere. So how can those through whom they commit this injustice escape punishment? Whenever they are called to mischief, they respond with ‘Labbaik’ and come forward; when they are called to prayer, they turn their faces and go the other way. So the notion that the common people are innocent is not correct. The common people are involved in the injustices taking place daily in Pakistan. It is only a matter of power: whoever gets power commits injustice. So Allah the Almighty does not commit injustice. Now listen to the Hajj story: the Ahmadis who returned said that one day before the fire, at the Holy Ka‘bah the invitation to the Mubahala was formally accepted. Around the Ka‘bah the Ulema loudly summoned the whole nation and said: O God, holding the hem of this Ka‘bah we say that we accept, and that we are truthful; send a curse upon them, and if we are liars, send a curse upon us. The next day such a great calamity struck there that an outcry arose. At first they said about three hundred, now five hundred; bodies lie unidentified in their mortuaries. And what eyewitnesses have described is nothing but divine punishment; even then people were crying out: divine punishment! To this day it is not understood how such a terrible fire broke out so suddenly, surrounding people so quickly that they could not escape. They climbed the hills, because the soldiers whom the government immediately sent said: take them up to the hills – and in the hills the fire followed them. Some burned to death while climbing, some died of fear, falling as they ran, some were trampled. Doomsday had broken out. And it is on record: one day before, holding the hem of the Ka‘bah, these people had said: O God, we insist that these people are liars and all our allegations are true; therefore decide today. And the next day came the decision – the day adjoining Eid.

10 of 10 left today