7. (Continuation of an answer; the corresponding question precedes this excerpt. From the context it concerns the belief that Jesus (as) ascended bodily to heaven, travels in space and will return, and whether God breaks His own laws of nature for this.)
Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 May 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: (Continuation of an answer; the corresponding question precedes this excerpt. From the context it concerns the belief that Jesus (as) ascended bodily to heaven, travels in space and will return, and whether God breaks His own laws of nature for this.)
… They say that is not so, but that is exactly what they mean: with God's consent, with His will. Do you break your own law at will? If a lawgiver is good, he leaves room in the law; he does not break it. It is only ignorant people who make laws, make them defective and then have to break them. A good lawgiver leaves room in the law and does not break it. Why would Allah the Exalted need to make His laws and then break them, when the Holy Qur’an itself says that in My laws in the heavens and the earth there is not the slightest flaw? Have you never read it? Allah the Exalted says: there is not even so much of a flaw that if you cast your gaze and search whether some loophole may have remained somewhere, your gaze will not return to you tired. Then cast it again and search again whether there is a flaw – your gaze will return to you tired, unsuccessful and frustrated, but will find no flaw anywhere. So why would the God who claims that His law is so perfect break it? – God forbid, is He Himself ignorant? Therefore God's law applies equally to everyone. Even the prophets did not remain outside this law. No prophet says: I am above God's law. God saves them within His law. Otherwise, why did He command Hazrat Moses (as) to flee in order to save him from Pharaoh? Why did He instruct the Holy Prophet (saw) to migrate? Was even the ordinary law of the world, of Arabia, not subservient to him? And with Hazrat Jesus (as) this treatment, that in a universe in which there is no flaw He Himself creates a flaw? And as far as calculation is concerned, those with knowledge know that, mathematically, it is not possible at all to go faster than the speed of light – according to the calculation that God has created, the calculation of which the Holy Qur’an says that the moon and the sun will continue to run by this reckoning until the Day of Judgement and there will never be any change in their speeds. So look at the other verses of the Holy Qur’an too. Therefore you cannot take false refuge to save Jesus. If God did this to save him, that He broke laws, why didn't He save him from the Jews right there? He could have lifted him a thousand yards – the Jews would have reached a thousand yards! He had to place him in the fourth heaven? All laws destroyed, a treatment different from all prophets! Speak sensibly, fear God! The picture the Holy Qur’an has drawn of Allah's perfect power and wisdom – you will break it just to save Jesus? And you do not even consider what he will do when he comes. If the same old Jesus comes – if we accept what the mullah says – then what was he? To whom was he a messenger? To the Children of Israel or to Islam? To the Children of Israel. Was the Holy Qur’an revealed to him? Now tell me, how long is it since the Holy Prophet (saw) came while that prophet sits in space? Fourteen hundred years. Is he sitting up there as a non-Muslim prophet or as a Muslim prophet? [Interjection: That is the Christians' own concept, and the Muslims have their own.] Then he is not a Muslim? [No.] Then what will a non-Muslim prophet do when he comes here, when the Holy Qur’an says: a messenger to the Children of Israel? And one who does not change his religion despite the appearance of the Messenger – you will serve him? Speak sensibly. The Holy Qur’an says We made him subordinate to the Torah, subordinate to the Gospel; it does not even mention the Holy Qur’an, that he was made subordinate to the Holy Qur’an. So will he teach you the Gospel when he comes, or teach the Torah? Or will he himself be a Muslim, or will he give you royal refuge? Reflect a little, apply your reason, how this can be: Hazrat Jesus (as) sitting in heaven, the Holy Prophet (saw) appears, and he has no knowledge of it. And if you say he came to know, then God informed him directly. After coming to know, did he become a Muslim or not? He would have to. If he became a Muslim, how will he practise Islam? The teaching of Islam would be revealed directly on his heart – and if it was revealed directly on his heart, then a partner-prophet has arisen in the universe. All this injustice, all this mischief you want to bear so that you do not have to accept Mirza Sahib as truthful. You have made everything of your own false so as not to have to accept Mirza Sahib. This is a bargain of folly. Please sit down.