8. (Name: Khalid, non-Ahmadi, from Sialkot, here for ten years.) My question to you is: Mirza Sahib made his claim step by step, right? I don't have much knowledge, but as I have heard, first he claimed … [Hazrat: Imam Mahdi.] … Imam Mahdi, then so on. I don't have much knowledge, I am just telling you what I have heard.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 May 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Name: Khalid, non-Ahmadi, from Sialkot, here for ten years.) My question to you is: Mirza Sahib made his claim step by step, right? I don't have much knowledge, but as I have heard, first he claimed … [Hazrat: Imam Mahdi.] … Imam Mahdi, then so on. I don't have much knowledge, I am just telling you what I have heard.

I know it; I am telling you. The mullahs say that he claimed step upon step, which means he was making things up from his own ego: first a small claim, then a bigger one, then a bigger one still, until he finally called himself a Prophet of Allah – although he said 'Ummati prophet', he did say it, he also claimed prophethood. And he did not stop there: he also claimed to be Krishna – that he was the Krishna the Hindus were awaiting. Then he claimed to be Buddha too, Zoroaster too; all those who were to come in this age were he. The mullahs mock this heavily and say: look, the gentleman has become everything! And they say this proves the claims were of the ego: one claim after another, further and further. That is the objection, isn't it? [Yes.] Now hear the Christians' objection against the Holy Prophet (saw). The Christians say: first he became a messenger only of the Meccans, of his clan, and said: warn your relatives. Then he became messenger of Mecca and the people around, and called the idolaters. Then his boldness grew and he became messenger of the People of the Book too. Then he made a still bigger claim and became messenger of the whole world. This gradualness, they say, shows that he was – God forbid – a liar. Both objections have exactly the same form, both are absurd, and they prove the exact opposite result instead of benefiting them. Now I will explain to you the reason for this method. If someone claims he has done something and thinks people will garland him and rejoice, but as soon as he makes the claim stones start falling on him – if he is a liar, will he withdraw the claim or make a bigger one? [A bigger one.] If he is a liar he will withdraw it. Do you understand? Haven't you seen your politicians? They make a claim, announce it, give statements to journalists; if they start getting beaten a little for it, they say: we never said that, we were misunderstood. A liar cannot make a claim that results in shoes and stones being thrown at him; and if he does so by mistake, he repents and takes no further step. This is Allah's way with all prophets: it is a sign of their truthfulness that they are opposed. God takes no pleasure in opposition, it is not His purpose to cause pain to His beloved ones, but it is a necessity: until they suffer, their truthfulness cannot be proven. When the Holy Prophet (saw) made his first claim, there was severe opposition. Had he claimed for the sake of his ego, he would not have made a bigger claim next. First he made only the Meccans enemies, then all the Arabs; then by a bigger claim he made the Jews enemies, then by a bigger one the Christians, and finally, by becoming messenger of all nations, all nations. This is a sign of his truthfulness, not of his falsehood. Now hear about Hazrat Mirza Sahib: when he claimed to be the Imam Mahdi, do you know what 'welcome' the Muslims gave him? Fatwas for his killing were issued. When he said Jesus (as) had died, a fire of opposition broke out across India; even those who had supported him before became opponents. And as if that were not enough: in the Punjab there were many Sikhs; around our Qadian lived very strong Sikh clans. He announced that he was the saint whose coming Guru Baba Nanak had prophesied, and that Guru Baba Nanak was a Muslim and founded no new religion – so they too became opponents. By telling the Hindus that Krishna believed in one God and that he had come to them on Krishna's behalf, in fulfilment of Krishna's promise to come, all Hindus and all Aryas became his opponents. He made every remaining religion his enemy. This course of action is not possible for any human being unless he is truthful or insane – apart from these two it is impossible. If he is insane: people leave the claims of madmen alone; they die their own death. Madmen make a thousand claims in the streets, nobody says anything, children throw stones. [Questioner: But my point is, you gave the example of politicians – those are ordinary people in the world – and the example of madmen does not match either. All our prophets made their claim only once and in one step.] That is wrong; that is exactly what I have disproved. You have never read the Christians' allegations, never read the history of Islam. I began with the Holy Prophet (saw). I am not saying their examples apply to him; I am saying their examples are different and those of the prophets are different – neither like madmen nor like worldly people. Because prophets are truthful, their next claim is greater than the previous one. The greatest example is the Holy Prophet (saw). His first claim was not to be a universal messenger; in his first claim he did not address the Christians. The debate went on with the idolaters of Mecca, and the Holy Qur’an says: 'Wa andhir ‘ashiratakal-aqrabin' – warn your nearest kinsfolk. So he climbed a hill, gathered his relatives and warned them. But over time his claim grew. This is exactly what Christian orientalists, who attack Islam with knowledge of Islam, have put in their books and frequently used against the Holy Prophet (saw): see, he is a liar, because his claim grew gradually and he did not make it all at once; had he been from God, he would have made all claims at once. Now, is this objection against the Holy Prophet (saw) true or false? Reflect: is it not actually the case that the claim to be a universal messenger was made later? It dates from after the migration from Mecca. The first claim concerned the confrontation with the idolaters of Mecca; then gradually the People of the Book came in, the confrontation with the Christians began, and finally the last announcement: 'Qul ya ayyuhan-nasu inni rasulullahi ilaikum jami‘a' – proclaim: O mankind, I have been sent as a messenger to you all. There is gradualness in these claims. I am telling you it is your misunderstanding that claims that develop gradually are a sign of falsehood. If claims grow gradually and with each claim opposition grows, that is a sign of truth. That is what I was explaining, giving proof: liars who make a claim and, contrary to their expectation, instead of becoming popular are hated even more, make no further claims; they turn back. Prophets make greater claims despite opposition. This proves that they do not care about the world, they trust in Allah and Allah protects them. Understood?

10 of 10 left today