14. Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. [Name] from the … branch of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Huzur, my question is: there is wisdom in every act of Allah, but when a person falls ill – when small innocent children and adults are seen in such agonising illness that they die writhing in pain … And Huzur, some illnesses are caused by a person’s own carelessness, when he knows that a fatal illness can result from consuming those foods or things. Then is … [rest not preserved]

Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 May 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Assalamu alaikum, Huzur. [Name] from the … branch of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Huzur, my question is: there is wisdom in every act of Allah, but when a person falls ill – when small innocent children and adults are seen in such agonising illness that they die writhing in pain … And Huzur, some illnesses are caused by a person’s own carelessness, when he knows that a fatal illness can result from consuming those foods or things. Then is … [rest not preserved]

[Beginning missing] … A book of mine is currently ready for printing; the final fine corrections are being made. In it this very question has been raised specifically and in great detail with scientific references, and the answer is so long that in this small gathering I cannot present all aspects of a single question. If you read it, then tell me what objection can still remain for you after that. Whether illnesses or sufferings: one person is made of a lower degree than another, one of a higher degree, and so too appearance. So when you single out an illness, the real point is that one being is in pain and another is not. But one person is blind – is he in pain or not? One person is crippled and lame. And not only that: leave him aside – even if all were healthy, there would still be comparisons among them: one is more beautiful, one less beautiful; one strong, one less strong; one agile, one less agile. So [gap] … in comparison an objection arises. Start removing that objection, keep removing and removing it, and you will finally reach the point that Allah should have made the whole creation, at least humans, exactly alike: none with more intellect, none with less, none with a stronger body, none with a weaker one, none more beautiful … [gap] … If the differences between them – illness, health, etc. – did not exist, human life could not have developed, nor could animal life. Life would not have come into being at all, because life came into being precisely through this competition. Between death and life God established stages. This is a necessity that cannot be removed; if you remove it, the existence of man will end. Angels already exist, so what need was there to create man? Such questions have been raised there and answered in detail from every angle. But, as I have submitted, understand it briefly; giving a detailed answer here is not possible. All right. – (Huzur, there are some illnesses whose treatment is very expensive…) – [gap] … It is a fancy that there is treatment only [there]. In Germany there are, by the grace of God, so many cases about which mothers show me in meetings: look at this child, the doctor had said survival was impossible, now we are showing him to you … [gap] … Allah granted healing. So it is a fancy that only the rich can get treatment. In my view, most of the patients who have so far been healed by God were poor. The reason is … [rest missing]

10 of 10 left today