20. My name is Aris (?). [Inaudible] Why does Allah take us when we are dead, and not alive?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 May 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My name is Aris (?). [Inaudible] Why does Allah take us when we are dead, and not alive?

[Huzur repeats the question:] He is saying: when Allah takes us to Himself, why does He take us dead, why not alive? Is that right? Is your grandfather alive? – Yes. – Where? – In Pakistan. – Does he have pains in his body? – Not much. – Is he not ill? The poor ones are often ill, they have become quite old. – No. – A grandfather and not old, how can that be? But the grandfather is alive. What I mean is: the old people, the poor ones who have pains in their bodies and are afflicted with hardship – if Allah took them alive, Paradise would become Hell. [Rest inaudible]

10 of 10 left today