24. Amir Abdul Azim (?). [Thanks for reading material.] Huzur, the Bible clearly states that the nations settled in Canaan, because they are idolaters, should be destroyed, even their children; there is a command to kill, and sometimes, according to the Bible, Allah even punished for not doing so. In the Holy Qur’an too, in Sura Al-Ma'ida: 'O my people, enter the holy land.' Some verses later: then two of those who feared Allah, on whom Allah had bestowed favour, said: 'Enter – in brackets in Tafsir-e-Saghir: attacking them and advancing against them – by this gate.' And a few verses later their reply: 'O Moses, go you and your Lord and fight them.' This also shows they were commanded to fight. Why, when they had never fought them before? They were in Sinai, those in Canaan. Also: the Holy Qur’an calls Canaan the holy land – has it called any other region so, and why this one?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 May 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Amir Abdul Azim (?). [Thanks for reading material.] Huzur, the Bible clearly states that the nations settled in Canaan, because they are idolaters, should be destroyed, even their children; there is a command to kill, and sometimes, according to the Bible, Allah even punished for not doing so. In the Holy Qur’an too, in Sura Al-Ma'ida: 'O my people, enter the holy land.' Some verses later: then two of those who feared Allah, on whom Allah had bestowed favour, said: 'Enter – in brackets in Tafsir-e-Saghir: attacking them and advancing against them – by this gate.' And a few verses later their reply: 'O Moses, go you and your Lord and fight them.' This also shows they were commanded to fight. Why, when they had never fought them before? They were in Sinai, those in Canaan. Also: the Holy Qur’an calls Canaan the holy land – has it called any other region so, and why this one?

That was an age when it was customary for nations to invade one another, and this was no moral flaw. All the nations of the world, the great kings, the great heroes of that era you read about, seized lands by campaigns against each other. Those people had earlier campaigned against the people of Moses (as) and driven the Children of Israel out from there. The history of the Children of Israel begins with Hazrat Jacob (as) and extends very far; it had ups and downs. Sometimes the Pharaohs of Egypt subjugated them, sometimes nations from Babylon attacked them. So how do you know whether the region in which God commanded Moses was not previously in Israelite possession? As far as I understand from the Holy Qur’an, Moses was commanded to take precisely those regions where Israelites had once lived, and Moses was to retake them. In my view that city was such a city. Moreover, there was much idolatry in that city, and Moses (as) was commanded to take it so that you have a place, a base, from which you can spread your strength. This purpose is evident. Another purpose, I believe hidden in these verses: the Children of Israel wandering with Moses in the wilderness repeatedly demanded that they did not like wilderness life, and demanded city food: we are fed up with these quails and Manna and Salwa. Allah said: This is better for you, do not expect the lesser. But they would not accept. Then Allah taught them a lesson: the things you want, take them at the risk of your lives; if you want them, win them by fighting like men. When they got there, they all sat down. This means their demand was utterly worthless and futile. God was giving them food for free, they did not like it; and the food that the nations of the world had attained and were attaining, they lacked the strength to attain. Sitting at home they asked Moses for the food of city dwellers. When God said: Well, enter – then it became clear they were useless people. This incident exposed their weakness. Understood? Yet Moses and Aaron did not enter alone fighting, which means this was not God's aim at all; the real aim was to expose these people. – On the holy land: most prophets were born in this region, their history is associated with it, and decisions of the rise and fall of nations took place in this land. Hence it was declared the holy land. And with Canaan the Holy Prophet (saw) too was later to have a connection. This is a detailed historical debate, with differences between Christians and Muslims, into which I will not enter. But I want to say: a land becomes holy because of the prophets; no land is holy in itself. A land where good deeds took place is still called holy even if bad deeds also happen there. Mecca was sacred territory (Haram); even when idols entered it, it remained Haram. Therefore Allah declares holy those lands with which God's pure servants are connected.

10 of 10 left today