33. My name is Munawar Ahmad, from Rachna Town, Pakistan; my father is Rahmat Ali Sahib. I lived ten, eleven years in Kassel, for six months now near Gross-Gerau. In childhood we learned the method of Tabligh from Chaudhry Ghulam Qadir Sahib, a Companion of the Promised Messiah (as) and Maulvi Fazil; Murabbi Barkatullah Mahmood Sahib or Aziz Shah Sahib, and the Amir Sahib himself used to come. My brothers and I adopted that method here. So I brought Germans when you came to Göttingen in 1995, one family, later four families to Schaffhausen (?), last year ... near Marburg (?). But Germans who, without training, [join] after one or two days or one or two months, come to a meeting and later say we do not like it. Which of these two methods is better? And a small second question about children: my daughter was in fifth grade; in Ramadan the teacher said today's period is only on fasting, Aisha will explain since we do not know – why, for what reason, and how. She explained everything. 20–25 other Ahmadi pupils study at that school. I wanted to request that the older pupils there be permitted to adopt such a method.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 May 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My name is Munawar Ahmad, from Rachna Town, Pakistan; my father is Rahmat Ali Sahib. I lived ten, eleven years in Kassel, for six months now near Gross-Gerau. In childhood we learned the method of Tabligh from Chaudhry Ghulam Qadir Sahib, a Companion of the Promised Messiah (as) and Maulvi Fazil; Murabbi Barkatullah Mahmood Sahib or Aziz Shah Sahib, and the Amir Sahib himself used to come. My brothers and I adopted that method here. So I brought Germans when you came to Göttingen in 1995, one family, later four families to Schaffhausen (?), last year ... near Marburg (?). But Germans who, without training, [join] after one or two days or one or two months, come to a meeting and later say we do not like it. Which of these two methods is better? And a small second question about children: my daughter was in fifth grade; in Ramadan the teacher said today's period is only on fasting, Aisha will explain since we do not know – why, for what reason, and how. She explained everything. 20–25 other Ahmadi pupils study at that school. I wanted to request that the older pupils there be permitted to adopt such a method.
The good method is the one that bears fruit. Efforts that bear no fruit are a useless method. Are you a farmer or not? Who will tell you how to grow a good crop? It is simple: if a method makes the crop bear more fruit, that is the good method. Therefore every case will be decided according to the circumstances. Adopt those efforts for which Allah gives better fruit; where it is only banging your head with no benefit, leave it. All right. – As for the second: this question does not belong to this Majlis. Put it to your own Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat; do not ask me.