45. My name is Usman Hamid (?), my Majlis is … (unclear). My question is: is celebrating birthdays forbidden?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 May 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My name is Usman Hamid (?), my Majlis is … (unclear). My question is: is celebrating birthdays forbidden?
I mean, birthdays are celebrated as a result of blind imitation of the Western nations. But the prophet whom they believe in, whom they call the son of God – ask them whether his birthday was ever celebrated. Nowhere. The Holy Prophet (saw) – did the Companions (ra) ever celebrate a birthday? Did the Caliphs ever celebrate a birthday? Those people who are the masterpiece of the earth, for whose sake the world was created (?) – their day of birth remains completely out of sight; nobody celebrated a birthday. If celebrating birthdays had been a good thing, the birthdays of the prophets should have been celebrated. But the prophets neither celebrated their own birthday nor those of earlier prophets, nor did the servants of the prophets and their families celebrate the birthdays of their prophets. Therefore this concept of celebrating birthdays is futile and false. [Follow-up inaudible] I am listening. If you put a great deal of filth into milk, will you drink it? No. If you put just a tiny bit – what's the harm – will you drink it? No. It is the same thing: small birthday, big birthday – these are two names for one and the same thing. Will you drink milk with two or three flies in it? Small, and nobody is watching … putting a little in and drinking the milk with nobody watching … What is bad outside, that …