7. (Ilyas Mahmood Chattha from Karachi, Pakistan.) Huzoor, first: what is Islam's position on making a video of the deceased / the funeral prayer? Second: when non-Ahmadis come to offer condolences for a deceased person, they raise their hands in supplication; sometimes they come as a group, and if it is an Ahmadi's funeral they also say right on arriving: let us raise our hands. Should one refuse in that case?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 July 1997
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Ilyas Mahmood Chattha from Karachi, Pakistan.) Huzoor, first: what is Islam's position on making a video of the deceased / the funeral prayer? Second: when non-Ahmadis come to offer condolences for a deceased person, they raise their hands in supplication; sometimes they come as a group, and if it is an Ahmadi's funeral they also say right on arriving: let us raise our hands. Should one refuse in that case?
[After a misunderstanding: 'wives' heard instead of 'video' – I was wondering what was going on here.] Making a video of dead things is impermissible – is the question whether it is permissible? When you make a video, how many dead things you capture; all the scenes are dead. So why did the thought occur whether it is permissible or impermissible? (Because at the funeral ... there was such a situation.) That means in your view making a video of the deceased is not impermissible. [Gap in the recording] ... but during the funeral prayer one should take part in the funeral prayer. Outside the funeral prayer, taking a photo or video of the deceased is not impermissible. – On the supplication: prayer should be purposeful, not for show. Whoever with such a group does like this [raising hands] and like this [lowering], does so merely for show, to tell them that we perform the same rituals as you. In principle this is wrong. Whoever wants to pray for a deceased person can pray at home as well, and can pray there individually; but raising hands with the whole gathering and making it obligatory is not right. This is ritual and custom; God Almighty has no interest in such prayers. I remember when Kausar Niazi Sahib's son died, before going to condole I sent him word: I do not believe in ritual and custom; I will come and condole, people will see me and raise their hands, I will not raise my hands with them. If this is acceptable to you I will come, otherwise not. He sent word back: I will tell all my companions that this visitor will not make a ritual prayer, and will wish my son well, and if he wishes he will pray on his own. So no trouble arose. So send word to such visitors, about whom one mostly knows, and tell them the reason: we do not get involved in these customs; whoever wants to pray should pray on his own. Raising and lowering hands is an exercise in which nothing is said; leave it. (And if they say it right as they arrive, should one refuse?) What refusal? When they come to you, the question of refusal does not arise; nobody asks you, they just stand up. Whether you join or not – what refusal? If you don't want to raise your hands, don't; there is no compulsion that someone will lift your hands.