16. Muhammad Akram Khalid from New Jersey, USA, asks: In the Holy Qur’an there is the command to cut off the hand of a thief. Kindly explain: when should this command be enforced?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 July 1997

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Muhammad Akram Khalid from New Jersey, USA, asks: In the Holy Qur’an there is the command to cut off the hand of a thief. Kindly explain: when should this command be enforced?

Nowadays it should not be enforced at all, because most are thieves and liars. In a society which … [uncertain, possibly ‘is not reformed’], the Shariah cannot be acted upon. This is something I have told the intellectuals of Pakistan again and again and drawn their attention to: how will you enforce the Shariah in this society? The thief's hands will be cut off – you are all thieves. All of you, from your President downward, are thieves in your own affairs. I am not the one saying this; their own opposition is saying it. … [gap] … all the witnesses or lawyers or those presenting a case … lying was invariably part of every case. When this is the state of affairs, how can the punishment of cutting the hand of a thief be carried out? There, if you call out in the streets, ten, ten … nowadays for [gap] thousand they would testify against it – there the Shariah cannot work. The Holy Prophet (saw) [gap] … before that he had already reformed morals, and society had to a large extent been purified of evils. There lying was a rarity and truth was the normal state. Even in such a situation there are restrictions on witnesses – so much so that if it is proven about one of four witnesses that he was urinating in a corner in the bazaar, then according to Fiqh the testimony of such a person will not be accepted. Tell me, how will the Shariah be implemented there? There, in every street, you will see people urinating and … cleaning themselves [uncertain]. Look at reality. Proclaiming a fictitious Shariah is not enough. [rest unintelligible]

10 of 10 left today