4. My name is Manawwar …, my father is from Rachna Town in Pakistan, Rahmat Ali Sahib. I first lived ten or eleven years in Kassel and have now been near Gross-Gerau for six months. The method of Tabligh we learned in childhood – from Chaudhry Ghulam Qadir Sahib, a companion who was also a Maulvi Fazil; we watched this method all day; the missionaries were Barkatullah Mahmood Sahib or Aziz Shah Sahib, and the Amir Sahib also came there – I and my brothers have personally followed that method here. I brought families to your visits, in 1995 to Göttingen, and last year three of four families to Schaffhausen. On the other hand, there are Germans who without any training join after one or two days or a month or two, come to a meeting, only temporarily, and later say: we find no pleasure in it. Which of these two methods is better?

Urdu question-and-answer session, December 1998

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: My name is Manawwar …, my father is from Rachna Town in Pakistan, Rahmat Ali Sahib. I first lived ten or eleven years in Kassel and have now been near Gross-Gerau for six months. The method of Tabligh we learned in childhood – from Chaudhry Ghulam Qadir Sahib, a companion who was also a Maulvi Fazil; we watched this method all day; the missionaries were Barkatullah Mahmood Sahib or Aziz Shah Sahib, and the Amir Sahib also came there – I and my brothers have personally followed that method here. I brought families to your visits, in 1995 to Göttingen, and last year three of four families to Schaffhausen. On the other hand, there are Germans who without any training join after one or two days or a month or two, come to a meeting, only temporarily, and later say: we find no pleasure in it. Which of these two methods is better?

The good method is the one that bears good fruit. Efforts that bear no fruit are a useless method. Are you a farmer or not? Who needs to tell you how to grow a good crop? It is simple: if a crop yields more fruit by a certain method, that is the good method. Therefore each situation will be decided according to its circumstances. Adopt those efforts for which Allah the Exalted gives better fruit; efforts that are mere aimless knocking about with no benefit, give them up. All right?

10 of 10 left today