14. My name is Ismail Ahmad. My question: the Hindus say a person has many births. Is that true?

Urdu question-and-answer session, December 1998

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My name is Ismail Ahmad. My question: the Hindus say a person has many births. Is that true?

Tell me, have you ever asked them whether these births are always in human form or in other forms too? No? Ask them. If you ask whether a person has many births, they are compelled to answer: yes, if a person has good morals, it may be that for some time he is not born at all, stays in the air after death, remains in the heavens, and when he is born it will be in human form – meaning he was a good person. And if someone is indecent, a bad person, ask them how his birth will be. They will say: he can become a dog, a cat, a mouse, even the worms in the stomach. The dirtier he was, the dirtier his birth. So according to their principle, if someone's father was bad, the dog in the house may be the father, if in this birth he came as a dog. These are absurd, indecent notions. Instead of wishing to return to the world merely according to your own fancy, ask the Hindus what birth means; their pandits will explain it, and then you will know these are fictitious, baseless things. Look, is the world dirty today or not? Have not most people become bad, committing injustice and cruelty, immoral, turned away from God? Right? Then after their death animals should increase and humans decrease, should they not? If the Hindu belief were correct, today's humans would die and tomorrow there should be dogs and cats, and humans should disappear. But dogs and cats are decreasing and humans are increasing. This shows their belief is completely wrong and baseless. Understood?

10 of 10 left today