4. This question comes from the ladies: Will Hazrat Masih Mau’ud (as) and Hazrat Mahdi Mau’ud (as) be one and the same person, whereas in the Ahadith it is stated that Hazrat Isa ibn Maryam will descend in Bait al-Maqdis and the Mahdi (as) will be from the progeny of Fatima and born in Mecca?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 March 1998
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: This question comes from the ladies: Will Hazrat Masih Mau’ud (as) and Hazrat Mahdi Mau’ud (as) be one and the same person, whereas in the Ahadith it is stated that Hazrat Isa ibn Maryam will descend in Bait al-Maqdis and the Mahdi (as) will be from the progeny of Fatima and born in Mecca?
These questions have been raised many times before and I have answered them many times: the sayings of the Holy Prophet (saw) that relate to one and the same subject should be viewed together. Otherwise some narrations come from certain groups and others from other groups, and the subject scatters instead of coming together. In this connection I tell you that in Ibn Majah there is a Hadith: “La al-Mahdiyyu illa Isa” – there is no Mahdi other than Isa, no Isa other than the Mahdi. This Hadith has been printed in Ibn Majah since long ago, and obviously even our bitterest opponent cannot say that the Ahmadis fabricated it for their purpose. The people who held the belief that Isa is alive and the Mahdi will be separate did not object to this Hadith, because they also had righteousness: whatever was attributed to the Holy Prophet (saw), however they interpreted it in their hearts, they did not reject this Hadith. And this is the fundamental truth which the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat accepts.
Our belief is that prophecies are not fulfilled word for word. Prophecies carry messages. If you chase literal prophecies, the whole system of religion will be completely ruined. [Someone’s phone is ringing … perhaps an urgent message.] I tell you that our belief is that if you show all the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (saw) as applying word for word, the whole system will be ruined, and things would have to be attributed to the Holy Prophet (saw) which cannot be so attributed to a human being, to the Wise One of the Ummah, whom God chose as the Wise One in the whole universe.
For example, this Hadith “La al-Mahdiyyu illa Isa” – we hold it to be correct because in our view the Messiah is not the old Messiah of the Israelites who is to descend from heaven. We hold it to be correct because someone from the Ummah of Muhammad was to be born with the qualities of that Messiah, who was to be given this title. If our inference is correct, there is no contradiction in this Hadith: the Mahdi was to be the Messiah and the Messiah was to be the Mahdi.
If you ignore this and get entangled in the debate of a literal descent, then one would have to accept about Hazrat Masih that he actually ascended to heaven with his body and sat down somewhere in the fourth heaven. That means his journey was not to the next world; within this very material universe he went and sat in the fourth heaven. And until he descends from there, the hopes for the reformation of Muslims cannot be fulfilled; until he physically descends again, the reins of Islam will remain in the hands of the mullahs – and that is exactly what they want.
So just reflect: if Hazrat Masih (as) actually ascended physically, this contradicts the universe that God Himself created. The Holy Qur’an shows that in the heavens and the earth that Allah created there is no contradiction, and the Holy Qur’an draws attention to this again and again. Yet this belief displays a contradiction. The reason is that, as God has created the universe, a speed faster than light is not possible at all – possible for the soul perhaps, not for the body. On this fundamental fact all the scientists of the world agree one hundred percent. They do not enter the debate of how fast a soul can move from one place to another or not, because the soul has no body. But as soon as you speak of the body, God’s universe rejects that a body can travel faster than light. So our debate is not how fast souls move from one place to another; our debate is that there is a final limit to the movement of a body which no one in the world can break. If you hold the belief that a body can break this final limit and go beyond it, then today all the intelligent scientists of the world will consider this statement false – something they have verified mathematically and always found true, something they confirmed after studying the entire world of black holes: that no one can deny that time stands still there where the speed of light reaches its final point. This is not the occasion for a detailed discussion; if anyone is interested, Einstein has shed light to some extent on the phenomena that occur when time stands still. But it is a fact that the Messiah could travel with the soul, not with the body. If there is a belief in a physical journey, then for the Holy Qur’an it is utterly false.
These clerics with whom we are in dispute speak of physical ascension and physical descent. They say Isa (as) disappeared somewhere with his body and stopped in a middle heaven, and when he descends again with the same body, his reign will begin and ours will end. Neither does he descend, nor are we freed from these calamities. This is an absolutely clear, unequivocal truth. Therefore I request intelligent Muslims to reflect and ponder on this: the Messiah is not to descend with his body. Had he been to, he should have descended by now to remove the calamities that have already befallen us. But the matter has gone beyond all limits. Just look at what is happening to Islam in Pakistan alone – it seems that no trace of Islam remains there except the speeches of the mullahs. The spirit of Islam has departed, and the Messiah is still sitting up there – what is he doing?
And keep another fact in view: if Hazrat Masih was to ascend physically and descend physically, then travelling at the speed of light he would have to cover 186,000 miles in one second. If he travelled at the speed of light, flying at 186,000 miles per second, only two thousand years have passed since he left, and to reach the extent of the universe at this speed ten billion years are needed. So according to the mullah’s account, if the Messiah began his journey with the body, he must be somewhere around here. He still needs about ten billion years to reach the extent of the universe. When will he arrive? And then, if he begins the return – he would have to turn back as soon as he touched it – and begins the return, ten billion years more. So as much time as the universe has passed since the beginning of creation, or since the beginning of matter, at least as much more would be required. Throughout this whole period calamities will cling to Islam – two times ten million years more, indeed twenty million years counting going and coming, we will sit waiting. This is such nonsense that it is impossible that those who regard the Holy Prophet (saw) as wise as God deemed him should attribute such nonsense to him. This is insolence. Therefore I invite you to sound reason, which God Himself created. If you reflect on these things, your heart cannot draw any conclusion other than that Mahdi and Messiah are in fact two names of one and the same person, who will be blessed by Allah. For Mahdi means one who is guided. So our belief is that the Mahdi receives guidance from God, and it is that Mahdi who will appear in this world as the Messiah. So I hope those who asked will reflect further from this aspect, because time is passing quickly, and this question requires such an extensive answer that if I were to explain in detail the points I have alluded to, it would take many hours.
Let me say just one thing: if literal prophecy is to be accepted as true, word for word, then before the descent of the Messiah, who will literally descend with his body, some other things must happen. For example, he is to kill the swine that will have spread in the world, break the crosses that will be the religion of the world, ride the donkey that will be the donkey of the Dajjal, and kill the Dajjal with his sword. If all these things are literal – leave aside other things – read in the Ahadith the mention of that donkey known as the donkey of the Dajjal: it moves on land at great speed; at sea it travels in the form of huge, magnificent ships and does not sink; on it are aid supplies and provisions which its owner, the Dajjal, sends to poor nations for the sake of his dominion. All these things are recorded in detail in the Ahadith. So until such a donkey comes into being which, in the words of the Hadith, travels through the world at such speed, in whose belly passengers sit, which takes the form of magnificent ships at sea, which flies in the air and above the clouds at great speed covers the distance between East and West in a single leap – these are all words of various Ahadith – the common denominator of all of them is that the Holy Prophet (saw) says that this donkey with these qualities will eat fire. Yet no donkey of that time used to eat fire. And he says this fire-eating donkey is the one inside which passengers will sit – why will they not be scorched by the fire? If it eats fire, they should be scorched. It is clear that the fire compartment is separate; even if fire is actually burning, no heat of it will reach these passengers. This description fits exactly all means of transport. The fire of the engine does nothing to the passengers. The fuel of an aeroplane blazes so frighteningly that it would instantly reduce every living thing to ashes, but for the passengers sitting inside it is cool, they have air-conditioning, they have no discomfort. The same is true of ships: I have gone down and seen the compartment where their fires burn – you cannot even imagine how frightening the atmosphere of the engine room is. Those poor people who have to work there have become used to it and work in it, but that fire does not reach the passengers. Exactly this picture has been drawn by the Holy Prophet (saw). So what is the state of these clerics, that they turn the words of the greatest prophesying Messenger of the world into children’s tales – tales that cannot be fulfilled? And if they really can be fulfilled, then this donkey must appear first. Until this donkey emerges, the Messiah cannot come, even if he were sitting two steps away. The appearance of this donkey first is necessary. So the clerics are making donkeys of their followers by presenting such stories literally – they are truly making donkeys of them. Neither will such a donkey be born, nor will we be freed from the clerics; the Ummah will remain caught in this misfortune. All right.