10. My question: after the Hijra of the Holy Prophet (saw), the majority of Muslims gradually migrated from Mecca. Did the Holy Prophet (saw) instruct them to do so, or was it in view of their circumstances? (Questioner adds:) He had clearly said that those there who can migrate should migrate with him – a clear command.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 5 November 1999
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My question: after the Hijra of the Holy Prophet (saw), the majority of Muslims gradually migrated from Mecca. Did the Holy Prophet (saw) instruct them to do so, or was it in view of their circumstances? (Questioner adds:) He had clearly said that those there who can migrate should migrate with him – a clear command.
It was clear that the migration took place by his command, not merely in view of circumstances. No, no – people there were also worn out; they wanted to migrate anyway after he had left. Migrating according to circumstances – that is rather (…).
10 of 10 left today