9. Sayyedi, people mention that they saw the Holy Prophet (saw) in a dream, but very few say that other prophets or righteous people of the Ummah appeared to them in a dream. What is the reason?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 19 November 1999
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Sayyedi, people mention that they saw the Holy Prophet (saw) in a dream, but very few say that other prophets or righteous people of the Ummah appeared to them in a dream. What is the reason?
First, the first point itself is doubtful. If the Holy Prophet (saw) truly appears in a dream, he cannot say two contradictory things. Some mullahs say the Holy Prophet (saw) appeared to them in a dream and said the Promised Messiah (as) is – God forbid – a liar. And others swear that the Holy Prophet (saw) appeared to them and said: He is truthful, he is mine. In Sindh too such an incident occurred, with Pir Pagaro. So the question is: if it really is the Holy Prophet (saw), he cannot say contradictory things. Those who believe in the Promised Messiah (as) can be certain that it was the Holy Prophet who confirmed him, and the one who did not confirm cannot be the Holy Prophet (saw). Now, there is a hadith of the Holy Prophet (saw) that Satan cannot assume his form. So the one who denies is Satan; that form cannot be that of the Holy Prophet (saw) but of someone else – a form made by one's own ego and given the name of the Messenger of Allah. Otherwise it is impossible for Satan to appear in the form of the Holy Prophet (saw). On the second question: people may not tell you, but they keep telling me that they also see other prophets in dreams. Generally, however, Ahmadis mostly see either the Holy Prophet (saw), the Promised Messiah (as) or the Khalifas. Others probably see too, but all those accounts are not collected with us. In many letters I learn that Ahmadis saw such-and-such prophet. I too once saw in a vision in Masjid Mubarak that all the prophets were gathered, and among them I saw the Promised Messiah (as), but I did not see the Holy Prophet (saw). At first I was surprised: all prophets are gathered but not him? Then it occurred to me that at this time the Promised Messiah (as) represents the Holy Prophet. That too was in the vision. I walked around and saw all the prophets on all sides, every kind of prophet; Hazrat Abraham was among them, and other prophets too. I cannot name them individually as if I recognised each name, but in the dream the impression, indeed the certainty, was that all prophets were gathered. And their faces were turned towards the East – towards the East because the Messiah was to appear in the East. Otherwise one would think everyone in the mosque would face the Qibla. But Qibla is a name for turning towards God; God is everywhere, in every direction God is Qibla. I interpret the dream thus: since the Promised Messiah (as) was to appear in the East – 'at the white minaret east of Damascus' – in this vision the Promised Messiah (as) was confirmed. Understood?