25. … Wasiyyat contribution – should it be paid on gross income or net income?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 16 June 2000
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: … Wasiyyat contribution – should it be paid on gross income or net income?
It should be paid on gross income; gross income is the real thing, otherwise many excuses arise. And those who raise this income debate make many deductions themselves. I also received complaints about some Finance Secretaries that they are Finance Secretaries yet do not pay their chanda correctly. When I had it investigated, it emerged that one said: first I deduct the tax withheld from me; then I deduct the car allowance, then the children's allowance; and he made many more allowances, so that from a monthly income of 25,000, after all deductions 5,000 remained. These are excuses of the ego. Every person should try to give as much chanda as possible; it causes no loss, it always brings blessings. I received a very interesting letter: a family in Canada – their income was not high then, and the man was unemployed, no one gave him a job. They said: we have to give 200 dollars chanda. Maulana … Shams had given a very moving speech that there was great need, and if necessary one should take a loan and give. So they took a loan and paid the chanda. The interesting thing is that immediately afterwards he got a job paying 200 dollars more than his previous one. Allah showed a sign that He had made up what they had given. Therefore God never lets anything fall short. It is my daily experience, such letters keep coming: those inclined towards religious sacrifice are given very much by Allah. So it is better not to get too entangled in the net-or-gross debate, and if one must calculate net, one should not net excessively.