12. My name is Nooruddin. My question: in this country some Muslims celebrate Eid on the fifth and some on the sixth. Why do they not celebrate together?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 March 2001
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My name is Nooruddin. My question: in this country some Muslims celebrate Eid on the fifth and some on the sixth. Why do they not celebrate together?
Ask those who don't. Each follows the view of his own mullahs. Regarding Eid there has always been disagreement and always will be. The reason is that some try to celebrate Eid according to the moon of Mecca, whereas the horizon there is different and here it is different. Some try to celebrate Eid according to the local horizon. And some find out from the observatory when the moon can be sighted and celebrate accordingly. So sometimes there are not two but even three Eids. The method of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is very scientific, and if these people used reason they would adopt our method; then it would be one day.