17. The second question: Huzur, what is the difference between an ordinary error and an error of ijtihad?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 March 2001
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The second question: Huzur, what is the difference between an ordinary error and an error of ijtihad?
An error of ijtihad is an error in the sense that if an error is made while attributing it to the Shariah, it means a wrong ijtihad was made; it then becomes the cause of spreading wrong meanings of the Shariah. Therefore, if an error is of ijtihad and truly an error, it causes great harm to people; those who follow that Imam get a wrong understanding of the Shariah in their minds. An ordinary error has no particular harm. Once Hazrat Abu Hanifa (rh), it is said, was sitting and it was raining outside. A boy ran very fast in it. Hazrat Abu Hanifa said to the child: child, be careful, do not slip. The boy was very intelligent; he stopped, turned and said: Imam Sahib, if I slip I will slip alone, but if you slip many people will slip, hundreds of thousands will slip; you walk carefully. That is quite right: an error of ijtihad is the error of an Imam, and an individual error is like a child slipping.