28. Islam has prescribed death as the punishment for a murderer. In this country, at times cruel people kill children or police officers; they are punished, but later on some ground they are soon released. Should such murderers not receive the death penalty in this country too?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 2 March 2001

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Islam has prescribed death as the punishment for a murderer. In this country, at times cruel people kill children or police officers; they are punished, but later on some ground they are soon released. Should such murderers not receive the death penalty in this country too?

If Islam were in force in this country, the punishment should be given. In any country where Islam is in force, the death penalty can be given, but it is not obligatory either. The heirs can also forgive. The heirs of the deceased have the right, if they wish, for the sake of the orphans left behind, to accept a ransom (fidya), as a result of which his life is spared. Islam has kept both options open. This religion is such that there is room for every possibility. Therefore, if someone is killed cruelly, there is no question of forgiveness, for example brutal murder, the murder of children and the murder of the elderly; in all such cases the judge (qadi) has the authority to sentence them to death without asking the children or the family. But if the circumstances are such that averting the death penalty benefits those left behind and they forgive him of their own free will, then in such a case it is permitted.

10 of 10 left today