26. (Surah Al-Imran:) ‘…and the family of Imran above all the worlds.’ The Shias say that the family of Imran here means the household of Hazrat Abu Talib, because his name was Imran and his kunya was Abu Talib. From the progeny of Hazrat Abu Talib, Allah chose Hazrat Ali and his descendants and Hazrat Fatima (ra) above the whole world. The proof, they say, is that when the command for Mubahala with the Christians of Najran was revealed, the Holy Prophet (saw) took Hazrat Ali, Hazrat Fatima, Hazrat Hasan and Hazrat Husain (ra) with him and went out for the Mubahala, and included no one else. The Shia inference is that the family of Imran in the verse means the Shia Imams whom Allah chose.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 18 January 2002

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Surah Al-Imran:) ‘…and the family of Imran above all the worlds.’ The Shias say that the family of Imran here means the household of Hazrat Abu Talib, because his name was Imran and his kunya was Abu Talib. From the progeny of Hazrat Abu Talib, Allah chose Hazrat Ali and his descendants and Hazrat Fatima (ra) above the whole world. The proof, they say, is that when the command for Mubahala with the Christians of Najran was revealed, the Holy Prophet (saw) took Hazrat Ali, Hazrat Fatima, Hazrat Hasan and Hazrat Husain (ra) with him and went out for the Mubahala, and included no one else. The Shia inference is that the family of Imran in the verse means the Shia Imams whom Allah chose.

The Shia inference is completely absurd. It has no connection whatsoever with this Mubahala. They have made up the ‘family of Imran’ on their own. The progeny of the Holy Prophet (saw) was not of the family of Imran. The Holy Prophet (saw) took his progeny with him in the Mubahala because the condition of the Mubahala was that you bring your children if you are truthful. And these were indeed the children of the Holy Prophet (saw), whom he wrapped in one sheet, saying that these are they. That is why the Holy Prophet (saw) did not include the other Companions but included his progeny. The inference you have cited from the Shias is entirely false and absurd; it has no relation at all.

10 of 10 left today