19. At the time of the claim to prophethood, Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra) accepted Islam without any proof; Hazrat Umar (ra) opposed for six years and then accepted Islam; the accursed Abu Jahl opposed his whole life and caused suffering. Hudhur, why is this so? Does this guidance come from Allah, or does each person's own heart reproach him? (Follow-up:) The Holy Qur’an says man has been shown two paths, that of the grateful and that of the ungrateful. Does man then make this decision himself?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 February 2002

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: At the time of the claim to prophethood, Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra) accepted Islam without any proof; Hazrat Umar (ra) opposed for six years and then accepted Islam; the accursed Abu Jahl opposed his whole life and caused suffering. Hudhur, why is this so? Does this guidance come from Allah, or does each person's own heart reproach him? (Follow-up:) The Holy Qur’an says man has been shown two paths, that of the grateful and that of the ungrateful. Does man then make this decision himself?

All guidance comes from Allah, but Allah does not guide anyone by force. That man has been given free choice is precisely the difference between man and angels. Angels have no choice whether to do something or not. What from Allah … [gap in the recording] … Umar (ra) refused very harshly for some time; indeed he left home intending to kill the Holy Prophet (saw). His sister had already become a Muslim. When he went into her house he saw that she was hiding something, a paper. He asked her: What are you hiding? They were verses of the Holy Qur’an she was hiding. Hazrat Umar said: Give it to me. She said: No, you are impure, you cannot touch this Book; first bathe and then [gap] … take it from me. … He came to the Holy Prophet (saw) and knocked at the door; Companions were sitting inside. It was asked: Who is it? He said: I am Umar. He (saw) said: Have you come with evil intent or good intent? He said: I have not come with evil intent, I have come with good intent. Then the Holy Prophet (saw) told one of the Companions: Get up and open the door. And so he believed at that very moment. After that his sword was always hard against the enemy and was wielded in favour of the believers. – (On the follow-up:) I have already given the answer: it is man's will.

10 of 10 left today